Key result
Patients with congestive heart failure required significantly less work to reach similar phosphocreatine depletion in calf muscle during aerobic (0.009 vs 0.026 W/kg, P<0.01) and ischaemic conditions.
Why the study?
Do patients with congestive heart failure exhibit altered skeletal muscle metabolism during leg exercise compared to controls?
Observational
Do patients with congestive heart failure exhibit altered skeletal muscle metabolism during leg exercise compared to controls?
Absolute Event Rate: 0.009% vs 0.026%
p-value: p=<0.01
Patients with congestive heart failure show greater phosphocreatine depletion for a given amount of work during leg exercise, suggesting intrinsic skeletal muscle metabolic modifications independent of reduced blood flow.
Supports intrinsic skeletal muscle metabolic impairment in heart failure; hypothesis-generating and requires prospective validation before clinical consideration.
Using 31P nuclear magnetic resonance, it has previously been demonstrated that patients with congestive heart failure exhibit a greater than normal phosphocreatine (PCr) depletion in the working skeletal muscles of the arm. We have studied the importance of the work necessary to reach a similar PCr depletion ([PCr]/([PCr] + [Pi]) = 0.5) in calf muscle. Our results show significantly lower values for patients with congestive heart failure in both aerobic and ischaemic conditions (respectively: 0.009 +/- 0.007 vs 0.026 +/- 0.013 W/kg body weight, P less than 0.01; 0.29 +/- 0.16 vs 0.90 +/- 0.25 J/kg body weight, P less than 0.01). 2. This original model of skeletal muscle exercise facilitates a comparison of PCr recovery rate due to a similarity in the PCr depletion and intracellular pH in the two series at the start of recovery. However, the PCr recovery rate is similar after both normoxic and ischaemic exercise, i.e. respective percentages of PCr increase in the first 25 s recovery spectrum were: (a) aerobic exercise, congestive heart failure 133 +/- 18%, control series 138 +/- 18%; (b) ischaemic exercise, congestive heart failure 114 +/- 13%, control series 118 +/- 12%. The absence of a difference in PCr recovery rate and the greater PCr depletion by ischaemic work in patients with congestive heart failure suggest modifications that cannot be explained by a reduced blood flow to the muscle. 3. When comparing the two series, intracellular pH evolved similarly in normoxia and ischaemia during both work and recovery. Thus, no increase in anaerobic glycolytic activity appears when equivalent PCr depletion has occurred.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marie et al. (1990) conducted an observational in Congestive heart failure. Congestive heart failure vs. Control series was evaluated on Work necessary to reach a similar phosphocreatine depletion in calf muscle during aerobic conditions (W/kg body weight) (p=<0.01). Patients with congestive heart failure required significantly less work to reach similar phosphocreatine depletion in calf muscle during aerobic (0.009 vs 0.026 W/kg, P<0.01) and ischaemic conditions.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: