Why the study?
Do automated techniques for the prothrombin time test reduce inter-laboratory error compared to manual techniques?
Do automated techniques for the prothrombin time test reduce inter-laboratory error compared to manual techniques?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Automated prothrombin time testing does not reduce inter-laboratory error compared to manual techniques, highlighting the need for regular calibration using a standardized system.
Approximately 70% of hospitals participating in the series of prothrombin time proficiency assessment trials organized from the National (U.K.) Reference Laboratory for Anticoagulant Reagents and Control and continue to use a manual technique routinely. The remainder employ a large variety of different types of automated procedure. A comparison has therefore been made of the performance with the recommended manual technique and automated procedures used in the prothrombin time test. There is no indication that automation eliminated local technique variables or reduces the inter‐laboratory error of prothrombin time estimations. Most of these instruments gave shorter prothrombin times than did the manual technique. The practical effect of this difference was reduced by the use of the prothrombin ratio system of reporting but this does not eliminate problems arising from some makes of instrument. The use of a specific correction factor for each make of instrument to compensate for the difference from the manual technique is not recommended. This is because there is too much variation in the performance of individual instruments of the same make. The only practical solution appears to be for all instruments to be calibrated regularly using the recommended procedure of the British System for Anticoagulant Control. The results may be then expressed as British Corrected Ratios.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Poller et al. (1978) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: