Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This editorial emphasizes the importance of ventricular interdependence in pulmonary arterial hypertension, where abnormal loading of the right ventricle affects left ventricular performance, and both respond to hemodynamic improvements.
This article refers to ‘Impact of lowering pulmonary vascular resistance on right and left ventricular deformation in pulmonary arterial hypertension’ by G. Roca et al., published in this issue on page 63–73. Pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) is a serious disease often accompanied by right ventricular (RV) dysfunction and failure. Survival in patients with PAH is strongly related to RV function.1 Recommended echocardiographic assessment for the prognostic evaluation in PAH includes myocardial performance index and tricuspid annular plane systolic excursion (TAPSE).2 These measures indeed have a prognostic value, yet they are angle dependent, potentially causing inaccurate measurements. Speckle-tracking (two-dimensional strain echocardiography) is an angle-independent, sensitive technique that provides reliable measurements of global and regional myocardial performance with increasing value above conventional measurements.3 In PAH, RV free wall strain emerged as an important predictor of outcome.4 In this issue of the European Journal of Heart Failure, Roca et al.5 demonstrated in their substudy of the IMPRES trial6 that RV free wall longitudinal strain (FWLS) is reduced in PAH patients compared with controls. Over a 24-week period, improvement in haemodynamic measurements was accompanied by improvement in RV FWLS. Roca et al. also observed that LV septal circumferential strain (CS) was lower in the PAH group compared with controls, while LV global and non-septal CS did not differ. Improvement in haemodynamic measurements resulted in improvement in LV global, septal, and non-septal CS. Changes in haemodynamic measurements were more strongly associated with changes in LV CS than with RV FWLS. The authors conclude that both RV and, to a greater extent, LV deformation are sensitive to changes in pulmonary haemodynamic measurements. The finding that RV FWLS correlates well with treatment effect is important. However, the results regarding LV deformation must be viewed cautiously. For example, the finding that LV CS is most robustly associated with changes in haemodynamic measurements, while baseline LV CS is not correlated with pulmonary haemodynamics, merits emphasis. First however, the question arises as to what the surplus value is of integrating LV and RV mechanics. For this purpose, we have to introduce the concept of ‘ventricular interdependence’, which comprises the interaction between both ventricles in abnormal loading conditions. Although PAH is defined by normal LV filling pressures, LV performance may be affected. Because both ventricles share the interventricular septum within the same pericardial sac, progressive RV pressure load leads to bowing of the septum towards the left ventricle, thereby disturbing LV geometry and impairing LV filling.7 In addition, LV preload is diminished by reduced RV cardiac output, resulting in LV unloading and atrophy, particularly of the LV free wall. This atrophy is accompanied by decreased force-generating capacity.8 As a result of the continuity of RV and LV muscle fibres in the superficial layer, RV free wall traction occurs parallel to LV contraction. Approximately one-third of RV systolic pressure and output results from LV contraction, and the LV free wall plays a pivotal role.9 Because chronic RV pressure load results in reduced LV filling and LV atrophy, LV contribution to RV output is reduced. Thus abnormal loading of the right ventricle affects LV performance due to both direct and indirect interaction, and vice versa, resulting in a further reduction in RV cardiac output. Keeping this concept of ventricular interdependence in mind allows us to take a closer look at some of the described results. First, the finding that LV septal CS was lower in PAH patients compared with controls is interesting. Under normal circumstances, the pressure of the left ventricle exceeds the pressure of the right ventricle. The interventricular septum withstands this pressure gradient by circumferential tension, just like the remainder of the left ventricle.10 This tension is characterized by a stress-free state throughout diastole, essential for septal perfusion.10 In PAH, however, when this pressure gradient shifts, LV geometry alters to a more D-shaped left ventricle. Although the flattened septum withstands this pressure load, it is threatened by substantial compressive wall stress, which impedes septal blood flow and affects septal performance.11 The results of Roca et al. regarding LV septal CS are in concordance with previous results in both acute12 and chronic RV pressure load.13 Interestingly, in patients with aortic stenosis and concomitant pulmonary hypertension, LV CS was not reduced.14 Apparently, RV pressure load, in combination with septal displacement, may be the primary cause of decreased LV septal CS in PAH. Another interesting finding by Roca et al. is that improvement in haemodynamic measurements was associated with improvement in LV global, septal, and non-septal CS. This improvement was more strongly associatly with increased LV CS than with increased RV FWLS. It is known that in patients receiving PAH treatment, the LV eccentricity index, an indirect marker of RV pressure overload, is more strongly associated with outcome than direct measures of RV function.2 Perhaps it is the case that after haemodynamic improvement, the opposite effect regarding septal wall stress can be observed. Decreased RV pressure load and restoration of septum curvature may lead to decreased septal wall stress which can be demonstrated by improvement in LV septal CS. It appears that restoration of septal displacement occurs in the early phase of haemodynamic improvement and LV septal CS is a sensitive marker for measuring these treatment effects. Still, how do we explain the finding that improvement in haemodynamic measurements was most robustly associated with improvement in LV CS, while baseline LV CS measurements were not associated with pulmonary haemodynamics? Interestingly, a similar phenomenon was demonstrated in patients with chronic thrombo-embolic pulmonary hypertension (CTEPH), when LV global CS was measured before and after pulmonary endarterectomy.15 The authors suggest that LV strain may be affected by many concurrent conditions, resulting in a range of strain values for any given degree of pulmonary hypertension. In the analysis of change in haemodynamic measurements, the effect of these confounding variables may be eliminated.15 An alternative explanation might be found in interventricular dyssynchrony. In normal hearts, contraction and relaxation of both ventricles occur more or less simultaneously. In patients with PAH, however, ventricular deformation is not uniform. LV free wall relaxation starts immediately after aortic valve closure, while the RV free wall continues to shorten, even beyond pulmonary valve closure.16 As described above, RV muscle fibres extend throughout the LV wall. Mauritz et al. observed that after pulmonary endarterectomy in CTEPH, both the RV and LV CS were resynchronized and end-systolic wall stress reversed to normal.17 Perhaps it is not the direct correlation between LV deformation and pulmonary haemodynamics that Roca et al. observed, but rather resynchronization of interventricular delay after haemodynamic improvement, which may have a positive effect on LV septal and non-septal CS. However, this link needs further investigation. In conclusion, because both ventricles are coupled in series within a surrounding pericardium, abnormal loading of one ventricle affects the shape and function of the other. In PAH, this ventricular interdependence can be demonstrated by measuring both LV and RV deformation. The results described by Roca et al. form another step in elucidating the concept of ventricular interdependence. Yet this complex puzzle is far from resolved. Conflict of interest: none declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gorter et al. (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: