Why the study?
What are the longitudinal determinants of blood pressure variability in youth?
What are the longitudinal determinants of blood pressure variability in youth?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The determinants of blood pressure variability in youth, including age, male sex, absolute BP levels, obesity, and low socioeconomic status, closely mirror established predictors of high cardiovascular risk.
Although the adverse cardiovascular consequences of hypertension are believed to depend primarily on the increase in average blood pressure (BP) levels, the degree of BP variability has been more recently shown to represent an additional correlate and possibly a causal factor of the hypertension-related organ damage. BP is a highly variable physiologic trait, its fluctuations being the result of a complex interaction between external environmental stimuli and the response of cardiovascular control mechanisms. BP variability is a complex phenomenon, including long-lasting fluctuations, consisting of day–night, day-to-day and seasonal changes, and short-term variations within the daytime and night-time periods. The role of BP variability throughout the day and night as a risk factor for cardiovascular complications was first suggested about 20 years ago in studies carried out with 24-h continuous intra-arterial BP monitoring [1,2]. Since then, the clinical assessment of short-term BP variability and of its role in cardiovascular disease has been promoted mainly thanks to the availability of devices able to provide ambulatory BP monitoring through automated intermittent arm cuff inflations, which allow the estimation of BP variability in a noninvasive and repeatable way. Several important methodological drawbacks of such a noninvasive intermittent approach to BP monitoring have been reported, however [3]. BP variability estimated by commonly employed noninvasive ambulatory BP-monitoring techniques has a limited reproducibility, lacks normal reference values and is importantly affected by the individual behavior during the BP-monitoring time. Moreover, the discontinuous low-frequency BP sampling provided by these devices limits their accuracy in assessing BP variability, mainly when focusing on fast BP changes [4]. An additional issue that needs to be carefully addressed when focusing on the clinical relevance of BP fluctuations is the close relationship existing between BP variability and mean BP levels, the degree of BP variability increasing with the increase in average BP levels [5–7]. In order to account for this phenomenon, different methods have been proposed for the estimate of BP variability and for the assessment of its clinical value that aim at correcting for the confounding effect of differences in average BP levels [8]. Although the cardiovascular consequences of BP variability have been examined in several prospective studies (see below), there is paucity of data on the determinants of BP variability, especially in the young [9]. The report of Li et al. [10] published in the present issue of the Journal of Hypertension provides an important contribution toward establishing the factors contributing to the degree of BP variability in young subjects. In this longitudinal analysis of an ethnically mixed cohort of 641 young subjects who were prospectively followed for up to 15 years with repeated (up to 12) ambulatory BP-monitoring sessions, age, male sex, average BP, adiposity and low socioeconomic status assessed at the baseline evaluation all predicted a higher 24-h BP variability in the following years. The results were confirmed in a multivariate analysis, in which male sex, absolute BP levels and indexes of adiposity (either body mass index or waist circumference) predicted both systolic and diastolic BP variability. African–American ethnicity was a predictor of diastolic BP variability, whereas father's low education level independently contributed to systolic BP variability. Strengths of the study by Li et al.[10] include its large size and an ethnically diverse population, which included about the same numbers of European-Americans and African–Americans. More importantly, for the first time BP variability was measured on several occasions (up to 12) through 24-h ambulatory BP measurements. Although not all of the participants performed all 12 ambulatory BP recordings, 55% underwent at least four visits. The authors analyzed data using a multilevel or hierarchical growth curve model, an empirical model that is particularly suitable to analyze longitudinal datasets containing multiple observations for each of several participants, in which there is not an equal number of observations recorded on each participant [11]. The model allows to fit a growth curve that represents the evolution of BP variability over time for each individual and to analyze the effect of individual variables on between-patient differences in such curves. Thus, although the association of BP variability with age, absolute BP levels and adiposity had been described previously [12], the study by Li et al.[10] represents the first systematic description of the longitudinal changes in BP variability and of its determinants in a cohort of young subjects. Another advantage of the study by Li et al.[10] is that the authors defined BP variability on the basis of the ‘weighted’ 24-h BP standard deviation [13,14], which is the average of daytime and night-time BP standard deviations weighted for the duration of day and night. In most previous studies, BP variability was calculated by taking the simple mathematical standard deviation of the average 24-h BP value, which is heavily influenced by the day–night BP difference [12]. Given the available evidence that a preserved nocturnal BP reduction has a favorable impact on cardiovascular outcome, whereas an increased short-term variability may negatively affect prognosis [8], an estimate of 24 h BP variability, such as the ‘conventional’ 24 h BP standard deviation, which is unable to separately quantify these two components, may fail to disclose the adverse consequences of wider short-term BP fluctuations. The weighted 24-h standard deviation of BP may thus be considered a better index of 24-h BP variability than conventional 24-h standard deviation because it removes the mathematical interference of night-time BP fall in the assessment of short-lasting BP variations, and for this reason, it has been shown to correlate better with end-organ damage [14]. The role of BP variability in the context of hypertension-related cardiovascular complications has been a matter of considerable debate. Several studies have shown that a high short-term BP variability is a predictor of target-organ damage [1,2,15] and of future cardiovascular morbid events [16–27]. On the other hand, BP variability increases with increasing average BP levels [5–7], and an increased BP variability may accompany high-risk conditions such as diabetes [28]. Thus, the question is still open whether BP variability has a pathogenetic role in cardiovascular disease (direct causality), or it is simply a secondary phenomenon of subclinical vascular changes (reverse causality). In the context of such a background, the study by Li et al.[10] was not designed to confirm or disprove either hypothesis, yet it demonstrates that the determinants of BP variability essentially coincide with the predictors of hypertension (Fig. 1). Overall, the factors that anticipate a high BP variability in youth, including age, male sex, absolute BP levels, obesity and low socioeconomic status, are by and large similar to the established predictors of high cardiovascular risk.Fig. 1Previous studies had shown that BP variability increases with increasing age [12,29–31] and BP levels [5,12,32]. In an early study, intra-arterial BP monitoring of patients stratified by mean 24-h BP into mild, moderate or severe hypertension categories showed that the amplitude of BP variation increased progressively with worsening hypertension [5]. In 124 hypertensive children, BP variability was independently related with 24-h BP and age [33]. In an elderly Japanese population, BP variability was positively correlated with age, average BP, body mass index and with ambulatory PP, a proxy of arterial stiffness [12]. The above findings, obtained in cross-sectional studies, are now confirmed by Li et al.[10] with a longitudinal study design. Although not compelling, the findings by Li et al. show for the first time that age, average BP and adiposity predict increased BP variability over the next years in young subjects. The mechanisms by which age, high BP and obesity may lead to an increased BP variability can be inferred from mechanistic studies. Increased short-term BP variability may result from a depressed baroreflex function, potentially associated with increased stiffness of the large arteries induced by aging, hypertension and obesity [34–37]. A blunted baroreflex function may lead to excessive BP fluctuations in either direction in response to physical and mental stimuli. Moreover, changes in respiration and rhythmic alterations in central autonomic drive mediated by baroreflex mechanisms are important determinants of short-term BP variability [38]. In experimental animals, reflex influences stemming from the arterial baroreceptors buffer spontaneous BP variability [39], and their surgical inactivation increases the magnitude of BP fluctuations [40]. The sensitivity of the arterial baroreflex and 24-h BP variability are linked by an inverse relationship, namely, the greater the BP variability, the lower the ability of the arterial baroreceptors to modulate BP and heart rate [41]. Reduced baroreflex sensitivity may thus contribute to explain the increase in BP variability determined by age, high BP levels and adiposity. These data also suggest the hypothesis that one of the mechanisms through which an impaired baroreflex sensitivity leads to a worse prognosis [42] could be an enhanced frequency and amplitude of blood pressure fluctuations. In fact, independently from the pathophysiologic aspects of BP fluctuations, a clinically relevant question is whether short-term BP variability, as assessed by noninvasive intermittent ambulatory BP monitoring, has an impact on the risk for future cardiovascular events. This issue has been explored in several prospective, event-based studies. Table 1 shows that a univariate association between high BP variability and a number of different cardiovascular end points is invariably present in different clinical settings, including the general population, patients with treated and untreated hypertension, patients with type 2 diabetes, patients with end-stage renal disease and stroke patients. When proper adjustment is allowed for the confounding effect of average BP, the standard deviation of daytime systolic BP is no longer significant in some of the studies, thus suggesting that part of the prognostic impact of BP variability is explained by its association with increased average BP values. However, the predictive value of the standard deviation of daytime or night-time systolic BP (or the corresponding coefficient of variation) remains significant in a multivariate analysis in at least nine prospective studies [2,16,18–21,23,25,27]. One problem inherent in using the standard deviation of BP to estimate the variability of this parameter is that it simply reflects the dispersion of BP measurements around a mean value, not accounting for the order in which the BP measurements are obtained. Two studies [22,26] in which BP variability was defined as the average of the absolute differences of consecutive measurements (the so-called ‘average real variability’) suggest that a formula of BP variability that is sensitive to the individual BP measurement order might be a better predictor of cardiovascular risk than the traditional standard deviation.Table 1: Prognostic value of blood pressure variability in published studiesThe study by Li et al.[10] provides an additional contribution to research in this field also by reporting for the first time an association between father's low education levels and increased BP variability. These findings complement those recently obtained by Chaix et al.[43], who reported, in 5941 French adults, that systolic BP increases with both decreasing individual education levels and decreasing education in the neighborhood of residence. In that study, body weight (expressed as body mass index or waist circumference) and heart rate modifications appeared to mediate the effects of both individual education and neighborhood education on BP [43]. Taken together, these data [10,43] may in part explain why people at low education and/or at low income are at increased cardiovascular risk, a finding that is not adequately predicted by current risk equations. Indeed, when assessing the atherosclerosis risk in communities, standard Framingham risk score underestimated coronary risk in people at low socioeconomic status (defined as <12 years of education or low income), and adding socioeconomic status to coronary risk assessment reduced this bias [44]. The findings of the study by Li et al.[10] should be evaluated against the background of the study limitations. Given that physical activity increases BP variability substantially [45], the effects of sex on age-related increase in BP variability could at least in part depend on a greater age-related increase in physical activity in boys than in girls. Unfortunately, data on physical activity were not available in the dataset. Moreover, the authors had recently reported that BP variability is not very stable over time in young subjects, with relatively low tracking coefficients for BP variability [46]. Other variables that have been previously shown to be associated with high BP variability, such as low birth weight [9], were also not taken into account in this study. Overall, the study by Li et al.[10] reinforces the view of BP variability as a significant determinant of cardiovascular risk by showing that the determinants of high BP variability in young subjects coincide with major risk factors for cardiovascular disease later in life. Yet, a link is still missing before recommending short-term BP variability as a cardiovascular risk factor on its own and a target of treatment. Despite data on experimental animals suggesting that the decrease in left ventricular and aortic hypertrophy may be independently associated with the treatment-related decrease in systolic BP variability and the associated increase in baroreflex sensitivity [47], proof is still missing from clinical intervention trials that reduction of overall BP variability might lead to reduction of cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. In spite of the methodological difficulties, this issue would deserve to be addressed in future studies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Schillaci et al. (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: