Key result
MOLLI underestimated myocardial T1 values compared to SASHA in healthy volunteers at baseline and post-gadolinium, consistent with T2-dependent errors.
Why the study?
Does the MOLLI sequence underestimate T1 values compared to SASHA and IR-SE in phantoms and healthy volunteers?
Cross-Sectional (n=10)
Does the MOLLI sequence underestimate T1 values compared to SASHA and IR-SE in phantoms and healthy volunteers?
MOLLI significantly underestimates T1 values in shorter T2 tissue-like phantoms and in-vivo compared to SASHA, which shows better agreement with gold-standard measurements.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Urges caution with MOLLI T1 values in practice; leaves open sequence standardization for quantitative CMR.
Diffuse myocardial fibrosis occurs in various cardiomyopathies and can be indirectly assessed with blood and myocardial T 1 mapping at baseline and after gadolinium administration. The widely used MOdified Look-Locker Inversion-recovery (MOLLI) [ 1 ] sequence is known to underestimate myocardial T 1 at higher heart rates, but its dependence on T 2 has not been explored. We investigate MOLLI’s T 1 accuracy in phantoms and confirm with simulations and in-vivo studies. T 1 values are further compared with a saturation-recovery T 1 mapping sequence [ 2 ]. 14 NiCl 2 agarose phantoms with a broad range of T 1 and T 2 values were imaged with a gold-standard inversion-recovery spin-echo (IR-SE) sequence, MOLLI, and a new SAturation-recovery single-SHot Acquisition (SASHA) technique (Siemens Avanto 1.5T). IR-SE : 16 TIs 100-5000ms, TE=11ms, TR>5s, 90° flip. MOLLI : 2 inversion sets of 3 and 5 images, 75% partial Fourier, TImin=110ms with 80ms increment, 35° flip, TE/TR=1.3/2.9ms, simulated HR=60bpm. SASHA : single-shot SSFP images from 10 consecutive heartbeats with incremented TI spanning the RR interval in the last 9 images (no saturation in the first image), 70° flip, TE/TR=1.3/2.6ms, full k-space, simulated HR=60bpm. T 2 : spin-echo (SE) with 7 TEs 11-200ms. Simulations: Bloch equation simulations of MOLLI and SASHA were performed in MATLAB using actual acquisition and physiology parameters and SE measured T 1 and T 2 values. For 10 healthy volunteers (5 male, 28.8±6.6yrs), blood and myocardial T 1 s were measured using MOLLI and SASHA (parameters as above) in a mid-ventricular short-axis slice at baseline and 20 minutes following 0.1mmol/kg Magnevist. In blood-like phantoms with long T 2 (179-196ms), SASHA and MOLLI T 1 s agree well with IR-SE (0.7±0.5% and 2.2±1.8% absolute difference respectively), while shorter T 2 (46-76ms) tissue-like phantoms have greater underestimation with MOLLI (8.4±3.5%) than SASHA (0.9±0.6%) (Fig. 1 ). MOLLI simulations predict underestimated T 1 s, with 1.3±0.9% absolute difference from observed values (vertical lines, Fig. 1 ). SASHA simulations also agree well with observations (0.8±0.5%, not shown). In healthy volunteers (63.3±8.4bpm), MOLLI T 1 s also show greater underestimation compared to SASHA in tissue than blood, although the difference is larger than observed in phantoms or predicted by simulations in all cases (Table 1 ). Error in MOLLI and SASHA T 1 values compared to gold standard inversion-recovery spin-echo (IR-SE) in "tissue-like" phantoms (T 1 s 339-1145ms) and "blood-like" phantoms (T 1 s 275-1452ms). A Bloch equation simulation of MOLLI using actual acquisition and physiology timing parameters is also shown, with the difference between simulated and actual results indicated with a vertical line for each phantom. MOLLI significantly underestimates T 1 s in shorter T 2 tissue-like phantoms but less so in longer T 2 blood-like phantoms, as predicted by simulations. Similar trends were observed in-vivo with MOLLI, although with greater T 1 underestimation (compared to SASHA) than predicted. SASHA had good agreement with IR-SE T 1 phantom measurements and simulations and can be acquired in less time than MOLLI.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chow et al. (2012) conducted a cross-sectional in Healthy (n=10). MOLLI T1 mapping vs. SASHA T1 mapping was evaluated on Baseline myocardial T1 value (ms) (p=<0.01). MOLLI underestimated myocardial T1 values compared to SASHA in healthy volunteers at baseline and post-gadolinium, consistent with T2-dependent errors.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: