This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
What will the medical curriculum look like in the future? We have seen enormous changes over recent years in the ways we teach and learn, especially with the increased use of small group and problem-based learning methods, more teaching in the community and shorter, more structured postgraduate training programmes. Many of these changes draw heavily on the SPICES model of curriculum planning in which student-centred approaches, problem-based learning, integrated teaching, community-orientation, elective study periods and systematic approaches to curriculum planning have been the building blocks of modern curricula across the world.1 Circumstances have altered substantially since the initial publication of the SPICES model. Medical teachers, managers and clinicians are facing different organisational and educational challenges in the continuous drive to achieve an effective balance between teaching, research and clinical work. For example, student numbers are increasing and there is a greater awareness that teaching and learning should be evidence-based and reflect changes occurring in clinical practice, health service management and clinical governance. In addition, the public expect to be served by an accountable medical profession in a cost-effective health service. Teaching hospitals remain the cornerstone of clinical teaching in the later twentieth century, but increasingly treat patients experiencing short-term and acute care episodes. Most other medical conditions are managed elsewhere in the community. These factors require the development of a revised set of principles to guide medical education in the new millennium. In recent years we have reviewed and learned from a large number of differing approaches to medical teaching in different parts of the world and would like to propose new strategies for future curriculum development. We have taken into account the growing impact of information technology, the emergence of problem-based learning as a teaching method of choice by many medical schools, the need for greater clinical experience amongst medical students and for more protected learning time during postgraduate training. The proposals are built on educational principles that are familiar to us all: respect for the autonomy of the individual while also recognising the power of group learning, the importance of critical reflection on practice, the direct relationship between assessment and learning methods, and the fundamental need to ensure that learning is context-based, relevant and meaningful in the eyes of the learner. First, medical programmes will be product-focused. By this we mean that curricula will increasingly emphasise clinical practice and be practice-based wherever possible. This does not mean a return to a wholly apprenticeship-based system. Rather, the principal focus will be on clinical work and the acquisition of professional behaviours. Students will learn about basic science by applying it in the context of real clinical problems. They will learn by doing, seeing and discussing mainly in structured, organised environments that are supported by modern technology and by feedback from patients. Programme planning will emphasise learning outcomes congruent with clinical practice rather than the use of educational processes or learning objectives. Second, learning will become more relevant both to communities and to students. Learning programmes that are planned around outcomes can link clinical knowledge, skills and behaviours to the needs of local health services and populations. The syllabus will be more frequently reviewed to ensure it is contemporary, and learning activities will be directly related to meaningful clinical tasks and to career development. Up-to-date teaching and learning resources will be selected on the basis of evidence-based decisions. Third, the medical curriculum of the future will be interprofessional in character. Programmes will espouse, encourage, and reflect a culture of effective, multiprofessional learning and value interdisciplinary learning experiences, with an expectation that teamwork and collaboration in educational, research and clinical contexts is based on mutual respect and understanding. Fourth, medical courses will be shorter and the numbers involved will be much smaller. This does not mean that the total number of students or participants will decrease but that learning activities will take place in smaller units, locally, wherever possible, and will combine modern technology with independent and open learning techniques. Outside North America, undergraduate medical courses will increasingly be reduced from six to four years by encouraging graduates and mature entrants to study medicine. Closer collaboration between teachers in medical schools and in hospital training will make the ‘continuous’ curriculum more attainable by easing, and finally dropping, some of the artificial barriers presented by transitions between the final school year and university, the preclinical and clinical years of initial medical education, and from undergraduate to postgraduate training. Fifth, modern medical education will be based in multisite locations. The narrow patient mix of teaching hospitals has resulted in students being increasingly educated in primary care settings, and smaller hospitals and units. The smaller units are unable to accommodate a large number of students at one time – hence the need for a greater number of sites. In the rural areas of some countries for example, where the medical workforce must be concentrated to meet population needs, multisite education will give students valuable experience, and equip them with the knowledge, skills and attitudes they will need to practise in such settings after graduation. Multisite education supported by information technology and open learning approaches, is more likely to provide a product-focused, relevant and interprofessional context for learning. Furthermore, extended experience in smaller sites will enable students to establish the closer relationships between patients and health colleagues that are essential for contemporary medical practice. Sixth, medical education will be symbiotic. We have compared the symbiotic curriculum with a prism (see Figure 1) to illustrate that the curriculum of the future will be seen as an organic whole with several constituent elements. The symbiotic curriculum. In the PRISMS model, clinical education is the driving force. The symbiotic curriculum must separate, and at the same time bring together in partnership, all six elements. Why are partnerships between learners, teachers, organisations, and the communities they serve, so important? They are essential as the health care agenda becomes more diffused, open-ended and contested.2 Doctors contribute only one voice to a health care system whose values, needs and demands are continually changing. Other voices in health care education, including those responsible for organizing and managing health care organizations, must achieve the same equality of importance if congruency and accountability are to be achieved. Symbiotic educational partnerships within a dynamic health care system must be diverse and flexible, recognise the existence of different learning styles, modalities and choices that seek to balance student-centred and teacher-centred learning approaches. Assessment will emphasise ‘doing’ rather than ‘knowing’, and continuous methods of formative assessment, such as portfolios, will predominate. Learning will take place within the health care system and the system itself will start to develop its own learning capacity.3 We hope that PRISMS will be a platform for future debate and a catalyst for new ideas, thoughts and discussions.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bligh et al. (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: