Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Clinicians should look more carefully for oxygen desaturation during exercise in some patients with HFpEF, especially those who are older, obese, have high left ventricular filling pressures, or pre-existing pulmonary disease.
This article refers to ‘Hypoxaemia in patients with heart failure and preserved ejection fraction’ by M. Omar et al., published in this issue on pages 1593–1603. Dyspnoea is an important symptom in patients with acute and chronic heart failure (HF). In chronic HF, various studies have shown that exertional dyspnoea is multifactorial and more complex than the single increase in pulmonary wedge with interstitial oedema and subsequent oxygen desaturation. It has been linked (without necessarily a cause to effect relationship) with pulmonary pressures, metaboreflex activation, pulmonary resistances, etc.1 It is classical to state that arterial desaturation during exercise should evoke pulmonary disease more than HF, as arterial oxygen tension (PaO2) remains generally stable in chronic HF,2 contrary to what may be seen in acute decompensated HF or in normal subjects (where it can increase). One should however note that most of these studies have been made in patients with HF with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF). Patients with HF with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) also complain of exertional dyspnoea. Studies have shown that exercise limitation in these patients is associated with diastolic dysfunction, pulmonary arterial pressure, but also chronotropic incompetence, obesity and poor peripheral oxygen extraction. In the study published in this issue, Omar et al.3 show that some patients with HFpEF (between 10% and 25%) also display oxygen desaturation during exercise, which is a novel finding in HF, although again this does not mean that dyspnoea is mainly related to oxygen desaturation; this abnormality also has prognostic value in their study. The authors correctly recognize that their patients were often more obese than HFrEF ones generally, and that the study was made in the supine position (which may alter pulmonary mechanics in obese patients). Also, they recognize that left atrial and pulmonary capillary pressures are much higher in the supine than upright positions, and this would favour greater development of lung congestion during exercise while supine by favouring fluid filtration out of the capillaries, would be expected to further impair V/Q matching and lung diffusion. Given these limitations, it would have been interesting to have not only a control group of normal subjects of similar age and body weight, but also of HFrEF patients exercising in a similar supine position. These findings add to the complexity of exercise limitation in HFpEF patients, which is not entirely surprising as the phenotypes of HFpEF patients are much more heterogeneous than the ones of HFrEF, where all patients have a final common phenotype of cachexia, anaemia, neurohormonal activation, deconditioning, renal dysfunction, arrhythmias, in addition to diastolic and systolic dysfunction. In which HFpEF patients should we suspect oxygen desaturation during exercise and track it? From the study, it seems that those with hypoxaemia were slightly older, more obese, and had higher N-terminal pro-B-type natriuretic peptide levels, displayed higher E/e′ and more severe right ventricular dysfunction. They also had lower forced vital capacity, forced expiratory volume in 1 s, diffusing capacity of the lungs for carbon monoxide, compared to those without hypoxaemia. Patients with exertional hypoxaemia had slightly lower resting arterial saturation, lower PaO2 and partial pressure of alveolar oxygen, higher alveolar-arterial difference, and greater dead space to tidal volume ratio at rest, with larger physiological shunt fraction. An interesting finding was the group differences in venous admixture during exercise, with nearly ∼3-fold greater physiologic shunt during exertion in patients with hypoxaemia. In summary, the main implication of this study is that we have to look more carefully for oxygen desaturation during exercise in some patients with HFpEF, especially the older ones, the obese, those with high left ventricular filling pressures and of course those with pre-existing pulmonary disease. Conflict of interest: none declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cohen‐Solal et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: