Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The author argues that the WHO polio eradication strategy ignored the protective role of naturally acquired immunity, inadvertently increasing the risk of severe paralytic polio outbreaks in developing nations.
To the Editor—Kew, in his editorial commentary [1], states that “the only source of immunity to poliovirus in all but a few parts of the world is immunization” (p. 1341). Before the World Health Organization (WHO) vaccination campaign, however, there was a very effective naturally acquired immunity to the virus, as has been noted by several authorities. For example, Krause wrote “before the introduction of modern sanitation, polio infection was acquired during infancy, at which time it seldom caused paralysis but provided lifelong immunity against polio infection and paralysis later in life” (p. 1075) [2]. These observations were especially important in the tropics, as Spalding emphasized in discussing poliomyelitis: “the disease is endemic and the virus is ubiquitous. Children who are exposed to it at a very early age rarely suffer permanent damage and acquire immunity” (p. 800) [3] Since the introduction of the WHO vaccination campaign, the situation has changed. If there is reinfection in a country where the wild virus has been removed, the first contact is no longer during infancy but later, during childhood or adolescence. Then these children or adolescents, not being fully protected by vaccination, are likely to become paralyzed. This is the probable explanation for the outbreak in Namibia, where children ⩽12 years old developed poliomyelitis, including 3 who had bulbar palsy [4, 5]. It has been confirmed that the source of this outbreak was Angola [6]. A more-severe epidemic occurred in Angola, where there were 1093 cases, including 89 deaths [7] At present, as a result of the WHO initiative, the wild virus is now confined to a few countries, but naturally acquired immunity has been lost, and the whole of the developing world is now vulnerable to epidemics of poliomyelitis, which could lead to severe paralysis and increased mortality. This has already happened as a result of the spread of the wild virus from northern Nigeria In considering the evidence presented here, and given the doubts about the clinical diagnosis of poliomyelitis [8, 9], it would have been more rational to introduce vaccination gradually and only when the infant mortality rate had decreased substantially. Before vaccination was available, Europeans who were living in Casablanca, Kenya, and South Africa had a much higher frequency of developing poliomyelitis than did the indigenous people [9]. Now, individuals in these developing countries with a high standard of living would be at a similar risk of becoming paralyzed, but they could easily be vaccinated Not all of the early pioneers concerned with poliomyelitis would have agreed that there was “a clear vision on how to begin the journey to polio eradication” (p. 1343) [1]. Macfarlane Burnet [10], in his classic account of the natural history of poliomyelitis, would not have countenanced the loss of naturally acquired immunity, and he may well have predicted that the present critical situation would occur
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
C.L. Crawford (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: