Why the study?
Does laparoscopic surgery improve intestinal recovery and reduce hospital stay compared to open surgery in patients with rectal cancer?
Does laparoscopic surgery improve intestinal recovery and reduce hospital stay compared to open surgery in patients with rectal cancer?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The perceived advantages of laparoscopic over open rectal resection may be diminished when compared to open surgery utilizing enhanced recovery protocols.
Sir We read with interest the paper by Lujan and colleagues which describes a prospective randomized trial comparing laparoscopic with open rectal resection. The study was well designed, adequately powered and had appropriate endpoints. They concluded that laparoscopic surgery is associated with more rapid intestinal recovery (mean 2·8 versus 3·6 days), a shorter hospital stay (8·2 versus 9·9 days) and less blood loss (128 versus 234 ml). These perceived advantages in the laparoscopic group should be treated with caution. The time to intestinal recovery and duration of hospital stay in this study were considerably longer in both groups than frequently demonstrated with the use of enhanced recovery protocols1–3. The greater blood loss in the open group is of questionable clinical significance. The laparoscopic approach undoubtedly has certain benefits compared with conventional open surgery but these are significantly diminished when comparison is made with open surgery conducted using minimally invasive techniques that are part and parcel of enhanced recovery protocols. It is the denominator that counts4.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Khan et al. (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: