Why the study?
Does multidisciplinary team management and exercise training improve outcomes in heart failure patients?
Does multidisciplinary team management and exercise training improve outcomes in heart failure patients?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Multidisciplinary team management and exercise training are beneficial and cost-effective strategies for improving functional capacity and outcomes in heart failure patients.
Heart failure represents one of the greatest clinical and economic burdens to the industrialized world. The disease is difficult to manage and carries a dismal prognosis. It is estimated that 4.7 million Americans have heart failure with roughly 550,000 new cases diagnosed every year. 1 Significantly, hospital discharges for CHF have increased from 377,000 in 1979 to 978,000 in 1998. In 1997, $3.7 billion ($5,501 per discharge) was paid to Medicare beneficiaries for congestive heart failure. 1 As the “baby-boomer” population ages, the economic burden to society will increase. The purpose of this review is to discuss team management concepts of heart failure patients, the emerging role of exercise in the treatment of heart failure, and whether cardiac rehabilitation centers should actively extend their reach to the specialized care of heart failure patients. Heart failure, which is simply the inability of the heart to pump sufficient blood to meet the demands of the body, encompasses a complex set of interactions among molecular, endocrine, and biodynamic systems. Current definitions of heart failure emphasize left ventricular remodeling and related cellular events. Myocardial injury (from ischemia, toxins, or volume or pressure overloads) or a genetic imperfection initiates the remodeling process. Remodeling involves myocyte hypertrophy, interstitial fibrosis, myocyte dropout, and changes in genetic expression of cardiac-related proteins. 2 As the disease progresses, there is a change in left ventricular chamber size and shape, and systolic and/or diastolic dysfunction appears. There are changes in the dynamics of the circulation, and metabolic abnormalities follow. Symptoms become apparent, initially during exercise, but eventually they are present even at rest. A variety of neurohormonal, peripheral circulatory, skeletal muscle, and respiratory adaptations ensue. Because of the multi-factorial, and often patient-specific, nature of the disease, treatment of heart failure is extremely challenging and patients require close monitoring. The primary goal for heart failure treatment is clinical stability and reduction of symptoms. Clinical signs of congestion (eg, orthopnea, weight gain, increased jugular venous distension) are important management issues to address. Additionally, treatment regimens seek to reduce neurohormonal changes, improve quality of life, and slow the progression of the disease. Treatment also targets aggravating factors such as atrial fibrillation or other arrhythmias, infections, endocarditis, hyperthyroidism, and hypertension to name a few. Medication regimens combine diuretics, inotropes, vasodilators, neurohormonal antagonists, and other medications specific to aggravating factors (eg, antiarrhythmics, anticoagulants). Administration of these medications is complex and requires meticulous titration, continuous reassessment, and follow-up. Adherence to heart failure guidelines such as those provided by the American Heart Association/American College of Cardiology improves outcomes. 3 Education and counseling of patients and their families with heart failure are vitally important for maintenance and stability. Suggested topics for patient education and counseling include explanations of the disease and disease process, signs and symptoms of worsening condition, self-monitoring, medications, and diet. 2 Recommendations for physical activity and exercise in the heart failure patient have changed substantially over the last several years. Traditionally activity was restricted, but recent research has demonstrated that both aerobic and resistive exercise programs can enhance exercise duration, prevent fatigue, improve functional class, and provide a general improved sense of well-being. 4,5 MULTIDISCIPLINARY TEAM MANAGEMENT OF HEART FAILURE Multidisciplinary approaches in the management of heart failure patients have evolved because of complexity of care, poor quality of life, frequent hospital readmissions, and the associated costs on individuals as well as society. Research has shown consistently that systematic follow-up and early treatment of symptoms can avert problems before they occur and reduce complications, readmissions, and costs. 6–9 A recent American Heart Association Scientific Statement examined the team management of heart failure patients. 2 Components of successful healthcare delivery models for heart failure include staff skilled in the understanding of the pathophysiology of heart failure, patient assessment and evaluation of symptoms, education and counseling (focusing on symptoms and medication compliance), dietary consultation, and physical activity and exercise recommendations. The Statement noted that there is considerable diversity among the types of management programs, and categorized them as specialty clinics, community outreach models, and primary care programs. Specialty heart failure clinics deliver care in the outpatient setting. Staff, trained and experienced in the treatment of heart failure patients, provide care that often begins before hospital discharge. Within the specialty clinic category, cardiologists are assisted by registered nurses who either coordinate or facilitate care. Or, care is managed and directed by nurses who have the primary day-to-day responsibility of care. Often, nurse coordinators or directors are advanced practice nurses such as nurse practitioners or clinical nurse specialists and have primary responsibility for day-to-day care. Research has shown consistently that outcomes have improved and costs have been reduced using these models. 6,9–12 Community outreach models involve care that is primarily delivered in the patient’s home. Rather than attending clinics regularly, patient management involves telephone calls or home visits. Again, these models can be either nurse-coordinated/facilitated or nurse-managed/directed. These models also have demonstrated improved outcomes and reduced resource utilization and costs. 8,13–18 Primary practice models that provide a program of increased access to care also have been described. 19 Care is directed by teams of primary care physicians and nurses who perform discharge planning, clinic appointments, telephone calls, and revision of plans of care. However, this is one of the few types of programs that has resulted in increased costs. While the outcomes from most studies examining specialty clinics and community outreach programs for managing heart failure patients are highly positive, comparison among programs is difficult because the independent variables differ. It remains to be defined which combination of multidisciplinary components, as well as the frequency of follow-up, provides the greatest value in terms of outcomes. It has been suggested that until research is available that defines the most important components, identification of the pieces common to successful programs can provide guidance to clinicians. 2 These components include such things as: □ care provided by cardiologists and/or advanced practice nurses □ comprehensive patient and family/caregiver education □ vigilant follow-up □ guideline-based optimization of medical therapy □ easy access to healthcare professionals □ early attention to signs and symptoms □ bio-behavioral strategies to improve compliance □ assistance in social and financial concerns. THE EMERGING ROLE OF EXERCISE TRAINING IN HEART FAILURE MANAGEMENT PROGRAMS Historically, patients with heart failure were advised to avoid exercise because it was thought that left ventricular impairment was a contraindication to exercise training. Patients with heart failure have significantly reduced cardiac output, either from low stroke volume or chronotropic incompetence. 20 One of the principle symptoms of heart failure patients is exercise intolerance. More recently, it also has been hypothesized that many of the secondary abnormalities associated with heart failure are the result of physical deconditioning. Several peripheral factors contribute to exercise intolerance and probably are responsible for the large variability between patient symptoms. These peripheral factors include skeletal muscle hypoperfusion and deconditioning, increased vessel wall stiffness, enhanced sympathetic activity, increased neurohormonal activation, abnormal vascular endothelial function, and impaired release of vasodilator metabolites from active skeletal muscle. 20 Physical improvements after exercise training probably are the cumulative effect of hemodynamic, histologic, and biochemical changes. 21 Research has revealed a number of beneficial effects of aerobic exercise in stable Class II and Class III heart failure with no increase in untoward cardiac events. 22 In fact, peak exercise capacity, as measured by peak oxygen consumption, is an excellent predictor of survival in the CHF population, 23 as are ventilatory and heart rate responses to exercise. 24 Importantly, improved functional capacity is linked directly to an exercise-induced increase in the oxidative capacity of skeletal muscle. 25Figure 1 summarizes some of the benefits of aerobic exercise in the heart failure population.Figure 1.: Improvements after exercise training in chronic heart failure patients. ANS, autonomic nervous system.Improvements in exercise tolerance, however, are not always consistent. One study examined whether certain subsets of patients respond better to exercise training programs. 26 Heart failure patients with normal responses to exercise were able to participate in training programs without difficulty and increase their peak exercise oxygen consumption more consistently than those with abnormal cardiac output responses. The authors postulated that patients with low cardiac output responses to exercise are limited by circulatory dysfunction and particularly by low skeletal muscle flow. They further note that these patients may have muscle deconditioning; however, it is primarily the circulatory dysfunction that is the limiting factor and the reason that these patients do not respond to training. Another small study was unable to show a sustained effect on quality of life or symptoms once the exercise training program ceased. 27 Among other things, these findings emphasize the importance of individual assessment and exercise prescriptions in heart failure patients. In the past, clinicians were concerned that resistance-based exercise would increase afterload, thereby decreasing cardiac output in the heart failure patient. However, resistance exercise is important in maintaining muscle mass and aids in the performance of the activities of daily living. It has been shown recently that isotonic exercise using hand-held weights does not decrease cardiac output despite increases in rate pressure product, blood pressure, and heart rate. 28 Additionally, a combination of aerobic and resistance exercise training improves cardio-respiratory fitness and skeletal muscle strength. 29 It is important that resistive exercise continue to be examined because of the potential value to the heart failure patient’s quality of life. The cost-effectiveness of exercise training in the heart failure population also has been demonstrated. In one study, a long-term training program in stable heart failure patients resulted in a cost-effectiveness ratio of $1,773/life-year gained. 30 A cost-effectiveness value of ≤ $20,000/life-year gained indicates a highly cost-effective program, which presents a strong financial argument for the incorporation of exercise training into treatment regimes. Numerous other studies have described cost savings using surrogate measures (eg, readmissions). 9 Comparing studies examining effects of exercise training programs can be difficult because of the variations in types of programs and endpoints. Most have had small sample sizes and were not randomized. Additionally, it is also not certain if (1) the effects of training can be maintained over the long term; (2) training is practical in different types of medical settings outside of specialty clinics; and (3) training would have an effect on mortality or morbidity, either adverse or beneficial. 5 Because of the issues outlined above, heart failure clinics that incorporate exercise in their programs of care should proceed with caution. Patients being considered for exercise training must be carefully selected. Those with exercise limitations due to peripheral factors rather than cardiac output are preferred as training appears to achieve the majority of its beneficial effects through peripheral mechanisms with little or no effect on resting LV function. 5 Exercise of low to moderate intensity for NYHA class I to III heart failure is preferred because it is equally beneficial as high-intensity training, carries a lower risk for muscular and cardiovascular complications, and is better tolerated than high-intensity programs. 21 Additionally, patients are more likely to adopt and sustain such an exercise program. MANAGEMENT OF THE HEART FAILURE PATIENT IN THE CARDIAC REHABILITATION SETTING Cardiac rehabilitation programs provide exercise training, multidisciplinary primary and secondary prevention programs, and psychosocial and vocational evaluation and counseling for patients with cardiovascular diseases. The patient population is predominantly post-myocardial infarction, bypass graft, angioplasty, and stable angina patients. The principal goals of cardiac rehabilitation programs are to lessen the risk of future coronary events, control symptoms arising from coronary disease, and to return the patient to optimal or previous functional status. The Guidelines for Cardiac Rehabilitation and Secondary Prevention Programs address the issue of care of heart failure patients within the cardiac rehabilitation setting stressing that they present a challenge to these programs and should be treated as high-risk patients. 31 They suggest that cardiac rehabilitation programs need to be modified for the heart failure population. Patients with heart failure should be thoroughly evaluated by their referring cardiologist before undergoing exercise training programs. The role of the cardiac rehabilitation center could include delivery of an exercise prescription, optimization of medication use, monitoring of daily weights, compliance with a sodium restricted diet, and surveillance for potential problems. In reality, however, most cardiac rehabilitation centers have not focused on patients with heart failure per se, but rather on heart failure as a consequence or comorbidity of myocardial infarction. Considering the increasing importance of exercise in the heart failure patient, and the increasing incidence and prevalence of heart failure, the question that one might ask is whether cardiac rehabilitation centers should extend themselves to include specialized care of heart failure patients. To that end, Table 1 compares the goals of cardiac rehabilitation programs with those of specialized heart failure centers. While both settings provide multidisciplinary care for patients with cardiovascular disease, there are striking differences in goals for rehabilitation and heart failure.Table 1: COMPARISON OF GOALS OF CARDIAC REHABILITATION CENTERS AND HEART FAILURE CLINICSMultidisciplinary Care The recommended core components for cardiac rehabilitation centers are listed in Table 2 along with the goal of cardiac rehabilitation for each component. 32 As a comparison, the goals for heart failure patients for each of the multidisciplinary components also are provided.Table 2: MULTIDISCIPLINARY COMPONENTS AND GOALS OF CARDIAC REHABILITATION PROGRAMS AND SPECIALIZED HEART FAILURE CENTERSSimilarities between the two programs include a mutual goal of smoking cessation and risk assessment and reduction techniques to prevent or control diabetes. The principal differences lie in the emphasis on exercise and risk reduction versus symptom management in heart failure programs, and, the focus on an acute cardiac event (eg, myocardial infarction, coronary artery bypass graft) versus a chronic trajectory. While reduction of risk is important in all patients, managing symptoms and preventing readmissions is the all-consuming focus in the heart failure patient. Because of the chronic and unstable nature of heart failure symptoms, long-term approaches are used. Cardiac rehabilitation centers traditionally have taken a more short-term approach, although some call for a focus on long-term adherence and follow-up. 33 Patient compliance in taking prescribed medications is a large part of heart failure management. Because of the complex and multi-factorial nature of the heart failure patient’s disease, patient education is geared heavily toward improving knowledge of medication actions and reactions as well as symptom recognition. Exercise goals are another major difference between the care of the two patient populations. The patient undergoing a program of cardiac rehabilitation attempts to achieve the maximal exercise capacity possible and to return to levels of activity experienced before the acute event or treatment. Exercise in the heart failure patient frequently is submaximal and focused on performing activities of daily living and preventing secondary effects of the disease process. Outcome measures also are different in the two populations. Return to a productive life and successful reduction or mitigation of risk factors are the goals of cardiac rehabilitation programs. Control of activity-limiting symptoms (mainly dyspnea and fatigue) and reduction of hospital readmissions are the outcomes of interest in heart failure programs. Is There a Fit? There are compelling reasons for cardiac rehabilitation centers to consider extending their practices to include specialty care of heart failure patients. The most obvious is that both patients are cared for under the specialty heading of cardiology. Exercise testing for the purpose of providing exercise “prescriptions” is done in both populations. Additionally, much of the equipment used to diagnose and treat both populations of patients is similar, thereby affording some economies of scale. It is not clear, however, whether there would be economies of scale with respect to personnel. While the personnel are similar, they must focus on vastly different objectives and goals for the two populations as described in Table 2. There are some potential problems that should be considered before extending cardiac rehabilitation care to heart failure patients. Personnel in cardiac rehabilitation centers have been reluctant to enroll heart failure patients due to the complexities in designing appropriate exercise regimens, concern over potential side effects from exercise, and the lack of Medicare reimbursement. 33 Although it is not known for sure, it is likely that heart failure patients need highly individualized “exercise prescriptions” based on their underlying pathophysiology, degree of disease, secondary effects from the disease, and other aggravating factors. It also is likely that these patients will require a greater degree of supervision, both by equipment monitors and healthcare providers, than the traditional cardiac rehabilitation patient. Lastly, there is a dearth of research supporting the fact that the treatment of heart failure patients in cardiac rehabilitation centers can be as effective as treating them in existing specialized heart failure clinics. Since the advent of clinics that specialize in the treatment of heart failure (many of which were established to address the unique needs of patients awaiting cardiac transplantation) the clinics have evolved into highly successful mechanisms for caring for this difficult group of patients. RECOMMENDATIONS Cardiac rehabilitation centers interested in extending their services to the heart failure population should formally articulate methods of care specific to heart failure and identify how this care would differ from their current plan of care for the acute coronary population. These centers must recognize that heart failure care is highly individualized and chronic in nature. They must articulate the adaptations that will need to be made for heart failure patients and determine if they will accept long-term responsibility for these patients or refer them back to the heart failure clinic. Secondly, studies are needed that provide evidence of similar or better outcomes of a combined program model for heart failure patients. Specifically, studies should compare outcomes (including costs) between treatment of heart failure patients within specialty heart failure clinics and cardiac rehabilitation centers. The potential for eliminating duplication of services and personnel is a compelling reason to consider extension of cardiac rehabilitation care to those with heart failure or, the incorporation of existing heart failure clinics into cardiac rehabilitation centers. However, because of the differing and complex nature of heart failure patients, this extension should proceed with the usual scientific rigor afforded other changes in care.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Caldwell et al. (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: