Why the study?
Does race affect renal function outcomes in treated hypertensive men?
Does race affect renal function outcomes in treated hypertensive men?
This letter cautions against concluding that renal function declines in treated black hypertensive men compared to nonblack men due to small sample size and socioeconomic confounding in the MRFIT analysis.
To the Editor. —In their analysis of renal function data from the Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial (MRFIT), Walker et al¹report that among all treated hypertensive patients and among those with controlled diastolic blood pressure (DBP, <95 mm Hg), renal function improved in nonblack men, but declined in black men. We believe that these important conclusions should be treated cautiously. First, as the authors state, the study is limited by the inclusion of only a small number of blacks, and second, the study fails to account adequately for the possibility that major socioeconomic differences might confound what appear to be racial differences. Of the 5524 hypertensive men studied in MRFIT, only 463 were black. The importance of this limitation can be seen, for example, in the analysis of the influence of blood pressure control on renal function among blacks. Surprisingly, blacks whose blood pressure was controlled (DBP, <95
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
David H. Stockwell (1993) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: