Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The challenge of a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve (BR) is balancing the sustainable use of ecosystem services with biodiversity conservation without compromising ecosystem integrity. To assess whether this balance is achieved, a quantitative assessment of ecosystem integrity is essential. However, ambiguity in its definition and the lack of a theoretical framework are obstacles. We redefined the ecosystem integrity as “a state in which the structure, function, composition, and self-organizing capacity of an ecosystem are not significantly different from that of the reference state”. Within a thermodynamic framework, this self-organizing capacity can be expressed as the ratio of entropy exported ( J ) to entropy produced internally ( σ ), i.e., | J / σ | . This metric was applied to 15 years of data from the Gwangneung Deciduous old-growth forest in Korea (GDK), a BR. The five-years before BR designation were assumed as a reference state, against which the subsequent 10 years were compared. During the reference state, | J / σ | was 0.76 ± 0.01, showing consistent self-organization. However, in the next ten-years, J was relatively constant whereas σ increased, leading to a decline in | J / σ | . This decline may result from the response of the old-growth forest to increased incoming radiation due to decreased precipitation. Notably, the decline in self-organizing capacity coincided with reduced tree species diversity (composition), increased deadwood (structure), and a shift to a carbon source (function) – all indicating degradation of ecosystem integrity consistently. These findings suggest that this holistic metric can serve as a complementary indicator of ecosystem integrity, alongside structural, functional, and compositional metrics for more integrative evaluation. • Ecosystem integrity was assessed by both holistic and reductionist perspectives. • An old-growth forest lost its self-organizing capacity, structure, function, and composition. • The decline in its self-organizing capacity may be attributed to climate change.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yang et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: