Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
National green building certification systems are increasingly expected to support whole-life carbon reporting, circularity assessment and policy-facing sustainability indicators. This paper assesses the methodological alignment of Türkiye's YES-TR system and DGNB with the EU Level(s) framework, using a structured qualitative crosswalk across objectives, boundaries, life-cycle stages, metrics, quantification requirements and evidence rules. The findings show that DGNB demonstrates stronger alignment with Level(s), particularly where life-cycle assessment, life-cycle costing and quantified building-performance indicators are embedded in certification logic. YES-TR covers relevant sustainability themes, including energy, materials, water, waste and indoor environmental quality, but its current structure provides weaker methodological equivalence for mandatory whole-building life-cycle global warming potential, material quantity and lifespan data, circularity metrics, adaptability and life-cycle cost. The paper also introduces Carbon Return Time as an interpretive lens for assessing temporal carbon trade-offs between upfront embodied emissions and future operational savings. The study contributes a transparent indicator-level comparison and identifies practical upgrade pathways for strengthening national certification systems as tools for whole-life carbon governance, public procurement, portfolio benchmarking and international policy alignment.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Duygu Erten (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: