Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper analyses how direct payments under the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) affect the economic results, the echo-schemes implementation consumption and ecosystems services of agriculture in Extremadura (south-west Spain). We use a crop-level cost model with 2015–2022 data and simulate CAP direct payments, including income support and eco-schemes. Results are complemented with indicators of eco-schemes’ cost-absorption capacity and crop dependence on three key ecosystem services—irrigation water, pollination and pest control—combined with stakeholder interviews and a producer survey. Without CAP support, most rain-fed cereals and traditional rain-fed woody systems (olive groves and vineyards) are economically unviable, whereas irrigated industrial crops and fruit trees are profitable. Unconditional payments reverse the deficit for nearly all loss-making crops, but rain-fed wine grapes remain structurally unprofitable and many rain-fed olive groves operate with very narrow margins. This weak performance creates strong incentives to convert traditional rain-fed vineyards and olive groves into irrigated systems, already visible in the region and associated with higher water use, landscape simplification and additional environmental pressures. Rain-fed cereals and legumes are better able to absorb the additional costs associated with eco-schemes, whereas high-value irrigated crops and rain-fed woody systems face tighter economic margins. Overall, the CAP in Extremadura functions primarily as an income-stabilization device and only partially as a driver of agro-ecological transition, calling for closer links between income support, farm structure, ecosystem-service dependence and land-use dynamics, and for eco-schemes that are financially attractive while discouraging the expansion of irrigation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thomasz et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: