Why the study?
What are the outcomes and mortality rates of mitral valve replacement with ball or tilting disc valve prostheses?
What are the outcomes and mortality rates of mitral valve replacement with ball or tilting disc valve prostheses?
Mitral valve replacement with ball or disc prostheses showed similar early mortality and haemodynamic outcomes, though multiple valve replacement and preoperative NYHA class IV were associated with higher mortality.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
High early mortality after mitral valve replacement warrants caution in high-risk patients; leaves open whether modern prostheses improve outcomes.
A survey is presented on the results of 100 consecutive patients who underwent mitral valve (78 patients) or mitral and aortic and/or tricuspid valve replacement (22 patients) with ball or disc valve prosthesis. The patients were followed-up from 6 to 54 months postoperatively. The mortality for mitral valve replacement was 13 (17%) early deaths (up to one month from operation) and 5 (6%) late deaths. The corresponding figures for multiple valve replacements were 9 (41%) and 3 (14%). A direct correlation was found between early mortality and preoperative functional class IV of the New York Heart Association (30% dead). Pulmonary hypertension combined with multiple valve disease resulted in an early mortality of 42%. No significant differences in early mortality figures after MVR were found between ball and disc valve prostheses. Predominant complications were respiratory infection and atelectasis (13%), acute myocardial infarction (11%) and haemorrhage (9%). Haemolysis was found in 9 patients and three other patients had haemolytic anaemia attributable to paravalvular leak which in two indicated the reapplication of the prosthesis. The main causes of death were heart failure, 8 early and 4 late deaths, and myocardial infarction, 5 and 4 respectively. Postoperative haemodynamic studies were obtained in 7 ball valve cases and 9 disc valve cases. Even the extreme degrees of pulmonary hypertension regressed markedly. There was no obvious difference among the ball and disc valve groups as to haemodynamic data.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kyllönen et al. (1976) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: