Key result
Real-time PCR detected enterovirus in 7.8% of clinical specimens compared to 4.0% by rapid cell culture, offering a more sensitive and reliable assay for routine daily use.
Why the study?
Does real-time PCR improve the detection of enterovirus infections compared to rapid cell culture in clinical specimens?
Observational (n=640)
Does real-time PCR improve the detection of enterovirus infections compared to rapid cell culture in clinical specimens?
Real-time PCR is a more sensitive and reliable assay for detecting enteroviruses in clinical specimens compared to rapid culture, particularly in cerebrospinal fluid.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May increase enterovirus diagnostic yield; hypothesis-generating for routine PCR adoption pending outcome validation.
Several real-time PCR and nucleic acid sequence-based amplification (NASBA) primer pairs and a modified real-time PCR primer pair for the detection of enteroviruses were compared. The modified real-time PCR primer pair was evaluated on clinical samples in comparison with cell culture using the MagnaPure LC Isolation instrument for nucleic acid extraction. Six hundred forty samples could be examined both by cell culture and real-time PCR. Faecal specimens (n = 285), cerebrospinal fluid (n = 210), throat swabs (n = 113), biopsies (n = 1--, vesicular fluid (n = 11), and pleural fluid specimens (n = 9) were included. By culture, 26/640 (4%) samples were positive for enterovirus. By real-time PCR, the number of positive specimens was 50 (7.8%). Of the 210 cerebrospinal fluid samples, three were positive by culture and nine by real-time PCR. Seventeen and 33 of a total of 285 faecal specimens were positive by culture and real-time PCR, respectively. In case of discrepant results, the clinical symptoms were in accordance with an infection due to enteroviruses. Genotyping using the VP1 gene correlated with serotyping by neutralization. In contrast, six of the 19 specimens that could be typed both by neutralization and by sequencing using the VP4 domain yielded a different genotype, yet within the same species. Real-time PCR turned out to be suitable for the detection of enteroviruses in the daily routine setting. In comparison to rapid culture, it offers a rapid, more sensitive, and reliable assay; especially in cerebrospinal fluid, the yield of enteroviruses is much higher.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Doornum et al. (2007) conducted an observational in Enterovirus infection (n=640). Real-time PCR vs. Rapid cell culture was evaluated on Detection of enterovirus. Real-time PCR detected enterovirus in 7.8% of clinical specimens compared to 4.0% by rapid cell culture, offering a more sensitive and reliable assay for routine daily use.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: