Key result
An alternative treatment was not significantly better than warfarin sodium for preventing venous thrombosis, and subcutaneous heparin was associated with problematic wound hematomas.
Why the study?
Does the 125I-fibrinogen leg scan accurately detect venous thrombosis, and is subcutaneous heparin better than warfarin for prevention in patients undergoing hip replacement surgery?
RCT (n=157)
Does the 125I-fibrinogen leg scan accurately detect venous thrombosis, and is subcutaneous heparin better than warfarin for prevention in patients undergoing hip replacement surgery?
The 125I-fibrinogen leg scan is a sensitive method for detecting venous thrombosis after hip surgery, while subcutaneous heparin prophylaxis is limited by wound hematomas compared to warfarin.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May warrant caution with subcutaneous heparin after hip replacement; leaves open optimal venous thrombosis prophylaxis.
One hundred fifty-seven patients who underwent hip replacement surgery were studied by the125I-fibrinogen leg scan technique. This method sensitively detects silent venous thrombosis and very small thrombi. By comparison with phlebograms, the isotope technique is somewhat oversensitive in that 26% of 46 phlebograms (12) showed no thrombi, but specificity was good in that on the basis of six other phlebograms, obtained because of persistent physical findings, the isotope leg scan was never "falsely normal." A two-phase drug trial failed to demonstrate an alternative treatment significantly better than warfarin sodium, but did indicate that wound hematoma occurring in patients given heparin sodium subcutaneously in the dosage used constitutes a real drawback for this therapy after orthopedic surgery.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Michael Hume (1973) conducted an RCT in Venous thrombosis (n=157). Alternative treatment (including subcutaneous heparin sodium) vs. Warfarin sodium was evaluated on Venous thrombosis. An alternative treatment was not significantly better than warfarin sodium for preventing venous thrombosis, and subcutaneous heparin was associated with problematic wound hematomas.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: