Key result
Averaging the results of stepping down to the first failure and stepping up to the first success yielded lower total error in estimating the defibrillation threshold than either method alone.
Why the study?
Does a combined step-down and step-up averaging method reduce total error in determining defibrillation threshold compared to single-direction stepping methods?
Does a combined step-down and step-up averaging method reduce total error in determining defibrillation threshold compared to single-direction stepping methods?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Averaging the results of step-down and step-up methods provides a more accurate estimation of the true defibrillation threshold than either method alone.
The voltage (or, equivalently, energy) at which defibrillation occurs for a specific episode of fibrillation can be represented by specifying or estimating the probability of successful defibrillation for each voltage or energy. This relation of voltage to probability is the probability function. For a series of attempts, the probability function predicts the frequency with which defibrillation will occur at a given voltage. By defining the defibrillation threshold (DFT) as the voltage at which the probability function takes on a specific value, say 50%, a method of defibrillation threshold determination can be evaluated by how accurately and precisely it estimates the "true" defibrillation threshold. By utilizing estimated probability functions from animals and humans, the relative performance of different methods of defibrillation threshold determination can be evaluated. Three methods were evaluated using published animal data and human clinical data: (1) stepping down to the first voltage that fails; (2) stepping up to the first voltage that succeeds; and (3) doing both 1 and 2 and averaging. In all cases, Method 3 has lower total error. Definitions of defibrillation threshold other than the 50% level can also be evaluated in this fashion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Church et al. (1988) studied Fibrillation. Method 3 (averaging step-down and step-up methods) vs. Method 1 (step-down) and Method 2 (step-up) was evaluated on Total error in estimating the true defibrillation threshold. Averaging the results of stepping down to the first failure and stepping up to the first success yielded lower total error in estimating the defibrillation threshold than either method alone.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: