Key result
The Foster equation estimated VO2max more accurately than the ACSM equation (mean difference 1.25 vs 9.40) compared to direct measurement in young men during treadmill stress testing.
Why the study?
Direct measurement of exhaled gases to assess VO2max entails high cost, making estimation equations a more convenient alternative.
Do ACSM and Foster equations accurately estimate V̇O2max compared to direct gas analysis in young adult males?
Cross-Sectional (n=41)
Do ACSM and Foster equations accurately estimate V̇O2max compared to direct gas analysis in young adult males?
The Foster equation is a more accurate estimator of V̇O2max than the ACSM equation for young adult males during treadmill stress testing with a ramp protocol, though it exhibits bias at the extremes of fitness.
May favor Foster over ACSM for treadmill VO2max estimates in young men; leaves open confirmation in diverse groups and settings.
B Objective: analyze the agreement of the V̇O2max values estimated by American College of Sports Medicine and Foster equations with direct measure gas analyze in young Brazilian males. The maximal oxygen uptake, as a health indicator and mortality predictor, can be assessed in different ways. The gold standard comprises the direct measurement of exhaled gases, which entails high cost. A more conveniently form can be estimation equations. Materials and methods: this study assessed VO2max of 41 young Brazilian males (21.4 ±2.2 years) by cardiopulmonary exercise test in a treadmill ergometer with a ramp protocol. Bland and Altman analysis was performed to verify the agreement between V̇O2max measured and estimated values by ACSM and Foster equations. Results: the measured VO2max was 52.3 ± 4.9 ml.kg-1.min-1. The difference between the measured V̇O2max and the estimated V̇O2max by the ACSM equation (9.40±3.67) was approximately 7.5 times greater than the difference between the measured V̇O2max and estimated V̇O2max by Foster's equation (1.25±3.46). Bland Altman graphics shows that only ACSM equation had mean differences that were significantly different from the measured value. Conclusions: the ACSM equation showed not appropriate for during treadmill stress testing young adults in a ramp protocol and Foster equation seems to be a more accurate estimator of V̇O2max for this population, besides showed a bias along the aerobic capacity, trending to overestimates and underestimates V̇O2max of least and most fit people, respectively.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
García et al. (2019) reported a cross-sectional. ACSM and Foster equations vs. Direct measurement of exhaled gases was evaluated on Agreement of VO2max values estimated by ACSM and Foster equations with direct measure gas analyze. The Foster equation estimated VO2max more accurately than the ACSM equation (mean difference 1.25 vs 9.40) compared to direct measurement in young men during treadmill stress testing.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: