Key result
Activity sensing pacemakers provided a more prompt rate response than QT sensing pacemakers, while maximum pacing rates during progressive exercise were similar (123 vs 129 bpm).
Why the study?
Does activity sensing compared to QT sensing in rate responsive pacemakers improve chronotropic response during various forms of exercise in patients with complete heart block and atrial arrhythmias?
Observational (n=14)
Does activity sensing compared to QT sensing in rate responsive pacemakers improve chronotropic response during various forms of exercise in patients with complete heart block and atrial arrhythmias?
Activity sensing pacemakers provide a more prompt rate response to exercise, whereas QT sensing pacemakers have a delayed response but offer a magnitude of rate response more proportional to the level of exertion.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Activity sensing may support faster initial rate adaptation in rate-responsive pacing; leaves open optimal sensor selection for clinical outcomes.
The rate responses of activity sensing (ATS) and QT sensing (QTS) rate responsive pacemakers to different forms and durations of exercises were compared. Nine patients with ATS and five with QTS were studied. All had complete heart block and atrial arrhythmias. At (he onset, (he pacemakers were programmed to achieve a pacing rate of 100–110 bpm by the end of stage 1 of the Bruce protocol, and to a pacing rate range of 70–150 bpm. With progressive exercise, using a treodmill (Bruce protocol), the maximum pacing rates in the two groups were not significantly different (mean ± SD; 123 ± 18 vs 129 ± 23 bpm, ATS vs QTS). The time taken to return to the baseline pacing rate during recovery was significantly longer with QTS (178 ± 70 vs 264 ± 68 s, p < 0.05). Brief exercise tests on a treadmill were performed for 3 min each with different combinations of treadmill speeds (1.2 and 2.5 mph) and gradients (0, 5, 10 and 15%). In both groups of patients, faster walking speed was associated with a faster pacing rate at each gradient. However, with increasing gradients, at each speed, there was a rise in the maximum pacing rate only in patients with QTS. During brief exercise tests, the maximum rate was achieved by the end of exercise in patients with ATS, but was delayed by 33 ± 20 s after exercise in patients with QTS. With very brief exercises lasting less than 1 minute (jogging on the spot), which require immediate rate response, patients with ATS had a rapid rate response and the maximum pacing rates were achieved by the end of the activities. The response of QTS was delayed and maximum pacing rate occurred during recovery. Ascending and descending four flights of stairs resulted in similar pacing rates in patients with ATS (100 ± 8 vs 105 ± 4 bpm, NS). Higher pacing rates were achieved on ascending stairs in patients with QTS (115 ± 24 vs 93 ± 28 bpm, p < 0.01). We conclude that with comparable pacemaker settings, ATS results in a more prompt rate response while the peak pacing rate of QTS is delayed. Rate responses are similar with gradually progressive exercise. However, the magnitude of rate response with QTS is more proportional to the level of exertion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mehta et al. (1988) conducted an observational in Complete heart block and atrial arrhythmias (n=14). Activity sensing (ATS) pacemakers vs. QT sensing (QTS) pacemakers was evaluated on Maximum pacing rates during progressive exercise (Bruce protocol) (p=NS). Activity sensing pacemakers provided a more prompt rate response than QT sensing pacemakers, while maximum pacing rates during progressive exercise were similar (123 vs 129 bpm).
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: