Key result
Replacing the 18G Contiplex needle with a Tuohy needle for paediatric caudal extradural catheterisation is unjustified and may increase the risk of dural puncture and traumatic nerve injury.
Why the study?
Does the use of an 18G Contiplex cannulated needle compared to an 18G Tuohy needle increase the risk of epidermoid tumour formation in children undergoing caudal extradural catheterisation?
Does the use of an 18G Contiplex cannulated needle compared to an 18G Tuohy needle increase the risk of epidermoid tumour formation in children undergoing caudal extradural catheterisation?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Replacing the 18G Contiplex needle with a Tuohy needle for paediatric caudal extradural catheterisation is unjustified and may increase the risk of serious neurological complications.
We would like to draw your attention to a recent change to the contents of the Caudal Extradural Catheter Tray (Oxford Set) Ref 4459105 (B Braun Medical Ltd, Sheffield, UK). The 18G Contiplex cannulated needle used to cannulate the caudal extradural space has been replaced by an 18G Tuohy needle with a Huber point. Initially we thought that this was a packaging error but we have subsequently discovered that B Braun Melsungen AG, Germany had instructed B Braun Medical Ltd, UK to make this substitution because they believe there is an unacceptable risk of tissue coring and epidermoid tumour formation using an 18G Contiplex cannula following caudal extradural catheterisation. Furthermore they fear that B Braun is likely to face medical legal action if this occurred. We disagree that there is a significant clinical risk of epidermoid tumour formation using a cannula to perform caudal extradural catheterisation for the following reasons: There is a theoretical risk of transporting nucleated epidermal cells to the extradural or subarachnoid space from hollow needles, and there have been isolated case reports in the literature following lumbar puncture in adults. However to our knowledge there has not been a single reported case of epidermoid tumour formation in children as result of caudal cannulation for extradural blockade. The most recent publication comparing hollow needles and needles with a stylet did not show a difference between the two needle types in the incidence of tissue coring and the incidence was very low [1]. Of greater concern of extradural anaesthesia is traumatic needle neurological injury [2–4]. The estimated incidence of this complication is one in 10 000. The reported risk of formation of epidermoid tumour formation from caudal extradural cannulation is considerably less than this. Indeed by replacing the 18G Contiplex needle with a Tuohy type needle with a Huber point the Tray has been rendered not fit for purpose because the Tuohy needle is not suitable for extradural catheterisation via the caudal route. If the Tuohy needle is used it would be extremely difficult to thread the catheter due to the angle of the Huber needle tip and there would also be a significant risk of dural puncture and traumatic nerve injury. Litigation following complications of medical intervention is a complex issue. It is the responsibility of medical practitioners who undertake medical procedures to use evidence based methods and equipment that is best suited for its purpose with due regard for patient safety. Furthermore the patient should be informed of the benefits and risks of the procedure. Consequently it is the medical practitioner who would be responsible in the event of a complication following extradural catheterisation. An equipment manufacturer would only be considered liable if there was evidence of equipment failure e.g. needle fracture. The Caudal Extradural Tray, Oxford Set was developed in collaboration between consultant paediatric anaesthetists in Oxford and B Braun Medical Ltd in 1997 following extensive research. The technique of extradural catheterisation via the caudal route using a cannula was first described by Bosenberg and coworkers in 1988 and is now in common practice in the UK, Europe and North America [5–9]. Furthermore we have published in Anaesthesia on the use of this tray of equipment ourselves [10]. It provides a set of equipment the components of which were previously only available from several different sets of equipment. Furthermore the tray provides uniformity of the components required to perform caudal extradural catheterisation enhancing patient safety and the teaching of the procedure to trainee anaesthetists. In designing the Tray we took due consideration for safety. The use of an atraumatic cannula rather than a needle as a conduit into the extradural space was selected to reduce the risk of neurological injury. We did consider the theoretical risk of implantation of epidermal cells and consequently included a skin lancet to incise the skin prior to insertion of the 18G Contiplex needle. This furthers reduces the very small risk of coring of nucleated epidermal cells. The use of the skin lancet is clearly demonstrated in the video commissioned by B Braun Medical Ltd as a training tool for caudal extradural catheterisation in children. The use of an intravenous cannula to cannulate the caudal extradural space in children has become common amongst anaesthetists for more than 10 years, indeed this technique is considered standard practice in many centres (personal communication). We believe that there is scant evidence to suggest that hollow needles such as the 18G Contiplex needle pose a significant risk of tissue coring and epidermoid tumour formation when used for caudal extradural cannulation in children. There is no justification for B Braun Medical Ltd in replacing the 18G Contiplex needle with a Tuohy needle and indeed this substitution may actually cause serious complications.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mason et al. (2008) conducted a letter in Paediatric caudal extradural catheterisation. 18G Contiplex cannulated needle vs. 18G Tuohy needle was evaluated. Replacing the 18G Contiplex needle with a Tuohy needle for paediatric caudal extradural catheterisation is unjustified and may increase the risk of dural puncture and traumatic nerve injury.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: