Key result
Antiviral hand treatment fails to reduce rhinovirus infections or common colds versus no treatment.
Why the study?
Does antiviral hand treatment reduce RV-associated illnesses in young adult volunteers?
RCT (n=212)
randomized
Does antiviral hand treatment reduce RV-associated illnesses in young adult volunteers?
Frequent application of an antiviral hand treatment did not reduce rhinovirus infections or associated common colds in a natural setting.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Does not support antiviral hand treatment for rhinovirus prevention; confirms lack of efficacy in this RCT.
BACKGROUND: Hand disinfection is frequently recommended for prevention of rhinovirus (RV) infection and RV-associated common colds. The effectiveness of this intervention has not been established in a natural setting. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of hand disinfection on RV infection and RV-associated common cold illness in a natural setting. METHODS: A controlled clinical trial was done in young adult volunteers during 9 weeks of the fall 2009 RV season. Volunteers were randomized to either an antiviral hand treatment containing 2% citric acid and 2% malic acid in 62% ethanol (n = 116) or to a no-treatment control group (n = 96). The hand treatment was applied every 3 hours while the subjects were awake. All volunteers kept a daily diary of symptoms and had a nasal lavage for polymerase chain reaction once each week and 2 additional lavages around the time of each common cold illness. The primary endpoint was the number of RV-associated illnesses. The incidence of RV infection and of common cold illnesses were evaluated as secondary endpoints. RESULTS: The hand treatment did not significantly reduce RV infection or RV-related common cold illnesses. The total number of common cold illnesses was significantly reduced in the intent-to-treat analysis, but this effect was not seen in the per protocol analysis. CONCLUSIONS: In this study, hand disinfection did not reduce RV infection or RV-related common cold illnesses. CLINICAL TRIALS REGISTRATION: NCT00993759.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Turner et al. (2012) conducted an RCT in Rhinovirus infection and common cold (n=212). Antiviral hand treatment (2% citric acid and 2% malic acid in 62% ethanol) vs. No-treatment control was evaluated on Number of RV-associated illnesses. Antiviral hand treatment applied every 3 hours did not significantly reduce rhinovirus infection or rhinovirus-related common cold illnesses compared to no treatment.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: