Key result
This letter discusses the terminology and construct validity of depression and anxiety measures in CABGS patients, highlighting the potential utility of the HADS tripartite structure.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This letter critiques the psychiatric terminology and construct validity of the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) used in a recent study of CABG patients.
We read with interest the article by Murphy and colleagues [1] and the authors are to be commended for identifying several factors that place patients at risk of having only partially remitting cognitive-affective depressive symptoms after coronary artery bypass graft surgery (CABGS). The authors’ unfortunate choice of terminology of minor and major depression is an inappropriate adaptation of psychiatric nomenclature reserved for use with structured psychiatric interview as performed by Strik et al. [2], who the authors cite. Given the descriptive labels remitted minor depression, partially remitted major depression, and worsening minor depression, one is lead to the conclusion that 100% of CABGS patients in Murphy et al.'s study had minor or major depression perioperatively, an alarmingly high prevalence if accurate. Perhaps the use of mild, moderate and severe depression or no depressive symptoms would be more appropriate. The authors also cite the work of Martin and colleagues [3], who have undertaken extensive research with the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS). Notably, the article they cite [3], among others [4, 5], has suggested that the HADS factor structure resembles a tripartite structure of anhedonic depression, autonomic anxiety and negative affectivity, rather than a simple bifactor structure. At the very least, these findings potentially compromise the construct validity of the HADS in cardiac populations, and may confound the trajectories of depression and anxiety symptoms reported by Murphy et al. [1]. Nevertheless, the HADS tripartite structure has potential utility to discriminate interrelated and overlapping depression and anxiety symptoms in cardiac populations. The seminal paper by Clark and Watson [6] proposed that negative affectivity symptoms were shared by depression and anxiety. Accordingly, in a recent study [7], we hypothesized that general negative affectivity symptoms would be predictive of unplanned readmission after CABGS. Contrasting to our hypothesis, significant independent effects were found for anhedonic depressive symptoms and autonomic anxiety symptoms. We believe that continued research in cardiac populations with psychometrically sound self-report measures will help elucidate the deleterious effects of the highly interrelated symptoms of anxiety and depression. The impact of psychological distress reported among myocardial infarction and percutaneous coronary intervention cohorts may not necessarily translate to patients who undergo CABGS given they are likely to be older with more comorbidity. Once again we commend Murphy and colleagues [1] for their excellent longitudinal study in a CABGS cohort.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tully et al. (2008) conducted a letter in Coronary artery bypass graft surgery (CABGS). This letter discusses the terminology and construct validity of depression and anxiety measures in CABGS patients, highlighting the potential utility of the HADS tripartite structure.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: