Key result
Impedance cardiography correlates with dye-dilution for stroke index but yields lower values and unreliable changes.
Why the study?
The reliability of impedance cardiography for determining absolute values and changes in stroke index compared to the dye-dilution technique was uncertain.
Does impedance cardiography reliably determine stroke index compared to the dye-dilution technique in human subjects?
Observational (n=17)
Does impedance cardiography reliably determine stroke index compared to the dye-dilution technique in human subjects?
Impedance cardiography does not reliably determine absolute values of stroke index or evaluate changes compared to the dye-dilution technique.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Impedance cardiography is unreliable for stroke index; challenges clinical adoption and leaves open validation of alternatives.
Stroke index obtained by impedance cardiography was compared with values obtained by dye-dilution technique in 17 subjects in 122 determinations made within 2 min of each other. Fifty of these determinations were done after drug administration, postural change, or saline infusion. All values obtained by both methods correlated significantly, but with wide scatter (r=0.49, n = 122, P less than 0.001). The series of determinations within each subject, however, correlated only in one subject significantly; thus any changes of stroke index measured by both techniques were not commensurate. In addition, the impedance stroke index values were significantly lower than the dye-dilution technique, impedance cardiography presently does not determine reliably absolute values of stroke index and is not suitable to evaluate changes of stroke index.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Keim et al. (1976) reported an observational. Impedance cardiography vs. Dye-dilution technique was evaluated on Stroke index determination (r=0.49, p=<0.001). Impedance cardiography for determining stroke index correlated with the dye-dilution technique but yielded lower absolute values and unreliable changes within subjects.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: