Key result
Depression assessment using the General Health Questionnaire was defended as a valid method for evaluating the link between depression and cardiovascular mortality after myocardial infarction.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The authors defend their methodological choices, including the use of the General Health Questionnaire, in evaluating the evidence linking depression to cardiovascular mortality after myocardial infarction.
We wish to respond to questions raised by Frasure-Smith and colleagues regarding our study, and to document differences in our interpretation of the evidence linking depression to increased mortality after myocardial infarction. In Table 5, we summarised previous studies selected using an objective criterion ( \(>\) 30 fatal events).1 For all established cardiovascular risk factors, an association with adverse outcomes has been observed across diverse populations. We therefore did not exclude studies because their subjects were participants in a clinical trial or cardiac rehabilitation programme, or because of usage of various medical treatments. We acknowledge that individual studies have limitations, but we are concerned that exclusion of studies from review on subjective grounds would bias evaluation of the evidence. The emphasis given to small positive studies, multiple reports from a single patient population, and studies reporting data only from selected subgroups, has also been misleading. In our study we used the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ), which was originally designed to detect general psychiatric morbidity in the community. There is, however, a close correlation between scores on the GHQ and scores on questionnaires designed to detect depression alone. In a systematic review of case-finding instruments for depression, the GHQ's sensitivity and specificity were similar to those of other self-administered “depression” questionnaires including the Beck Depression Inventory.2 In a previous analysis we assessed changes in mood over time among patients randomised to pravastatin versus placebo.3 The “Likert” method was used to score the GHQ for this purpose because it has a more normal distribution of responses. In the current study we wished to identify “cases” of depression at baseline, and therefore used the standard method to score the GHQ and prespecified the widely used “case” threshold of 5. Our results and conclusions were, however, similar irrespective of the method used to score the GHQ.1
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ralph Stewart (2004) conducted a letter in Depression and myocardial infarction. Depression was evaluated on Cardiovascular mortality. Depression assessment using the General Health Questionnaire was defended as a valid method for evaluating the link between depression and cardiovascular mortality after myocardial infarction.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: