Key result
PE prediction rules show similar accuracy to empiric clinical assessment for suspected pulmonary embolism.
Why the study?
Prediction rules for pulmonary embolism, such as the Wells score and Geneva score, require external validation and outcome studies to confirm safe patient management based on clinical probability assessment.
Do objective prediction rules (Wells score, Geneva score) provide accurate clinical probability assessment compared to empiric assessment in patients with suspected pulmonary embolism?
Do objective prediction rules (Wells score, Geneva score) provide accurate clinical probability assessment compared to empiric assessment in patients with suspected pulmonary embolism?
Objective prediction rules like the Wells and Geneva scores are valid tools for assessing pretest probability of pulmonary embolism, performing similarly to empiric assessment but offering advantages for less experienced clinicians.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Clinicians may rely on empiric judgment for suspected PE probability; leaves open whether scores enhance outcomes in prospective studies.
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The assessment of pretest probability, allowing the categorization of patients clinically suspected of having pulmonary embolism in low, intermediate, and high clinical probability, is an essential step in contemporary diagnostic strategies because it permits limiting the number of additional diagnostic tests, especially invasive tests. Clinical probability can be evaluated implicitly or by prediction rules. Two prediction rules for pulmonary embolism have been described: the Canadian prediction rule (the Wells score) and the Geneva prediction rule. Their original descriptions were published in 2000 and 2001, respectively. These prediction rules need to be externally validated, and, ideally, outcome studies should demonstrate that patients may be safely treated on the basis of the assessment of the clinical probability they provide. Therefore, the purpose of this review is to discuss the external validation of these rules, because this particular point has been only recently achieved. RECENT FINDINGS: Application of both rules in an external setting and in a prospective study have confirmed their validity. A recent study suggests that the best evaluation is probably based on a prediction rule associated with possible clinical override. SUMMARY: Studies comparing an empiric assessment with explicit assessment, such as the Wells simplified score or the Geneva score, have shown that the three tools show similar accuracy. External validation and use of both rules in prospective management studies have only recently been performed and have confirmed their validity. Some reports suggest that empiric assessment may be influenced by level of training. Objective prediction rules seems to be less influenced by experience and should be preferred by more junior doctors. The tool used for clinical probability assessment is probably less important than the principle of a careful clinical probability assessment in each patient with suspected pulmonary embolism.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Righini et al. (2004) conducted a review in Suspected pulmonary embolism. Prediction rules (Wells score and Geneva score) vs. Empiric assessment was evaluated. Objective prediction rules (Wells and Geneva scores) showed similar accuracy to empiric assessment for evaluating clinical probability in patients with suspected pulmonary embolism.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: