Key result
Among 24 interviewed heart transplant recipients, slightly more than half were satisfied with their physical activity, which was facilitated by intrinsic motivation and hindered by physical symptoms.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This commentary highlights the importance of understanding patient-reported barriers and facilitators to physical activity after heart transplantation to improve adherence to exercise guidelines.
This invited commentary refers to ‘Facilitators and barriers to perform physical activity in patients post-heart transplantation: a qualitative study’, by L. Klompstra et al. https://doi.org/10.1093/eurjcn/zvae144. Heart transplantation remains the gold standard treatment for patients with advanced heart failure worldwide. After transplantation, physical capacity increases significantly, particularly in the first few years after transplantation.1 Physical capacity is linked with recipients’ ability to perform physical activity and may also be a significant predictor of mortality post-transplantation, although more studies are needed.1,2 Physical capacity may be increased in heart transplant recipients through regular physical activity, particularly aerobic activity.3 Routine use of cardiac rehabilitation (either centre or home based) is also recommended after heart transplantation to improve physical capacity and potentially impact modification of cardiovascular risk factors.4 Cardiac rehabilitation programmes are associated with lower readmission rates post-heart transplantation.5 In addition to cardiac rehabilitation, specific recommendations from the International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation related to physical activity include encouraging a total of 150 min/week of moderate-intensity or 75 min/week of vigorous-intensity aerobic exercise.4 However, cardiac rehabilitation utilization remains low, and many recipients are not meeting specific physical activity guidelines with one study finding only 58% of recipients were exercising at least one time per week.5,6 Therefore, it is important to explore other ways that recipients may experience physical activity. Additionally, understanding the facilitators and barriers to performing physical activity from the recipients’ perspective may provide insight into strategies to help increase physical activity levels. Utilizing a qualitative approach, Klompstra et al.7 explored the experiences, facilitators, and barriers related to physical activity in post-heart transplant recipients. Utilizing interviews allowed the authors to explore the topic directly from the participants’ perspective and permitted them to elaborate on key concepts. Twenty-four heart transplant recipients were interviewed. In general, recipients engaged in more physical activity post-transplantation with a focus on aerobic activities such as walking and general activities of daily living, rather than resistance exercises such as weightlifting. While it is unknown exactly how much physical activity the recipients participated in routinely, slightly more than half reported being satisfied with their current physical activity level. Recipients reported being intrinsically motivated to perform physical activity through improved health and physical capabilities and found participating in physical activities with others more enjoyable than participating in physical activity by themselves. Additionally, recipients reported that being able to adapt to mobility aid use such as canes or walkers and/or having access to exercise equipment such as a treadmill or stationary bicycle increased their physical activity levels. On the other hand, barriers to physical activity included concerns for causing harm through participating in certain physical activities such as contact sports, unrelieved symptoms such as fatigue and dyspnoea, and an unfavourable outdoor climate that prevented physical activity. This paper adds a much-needed perspective on the barriers and facilitators to physical activity after heart transplantation from the recipients’ point of view. In addition to considering a referral to a cardiac rehabilitation programme, healthcare providers should ensure that health education and adequate assessment of barriers to physical activity occur. This includes educating recipients regularly about recommended physical activity levels and any activity limitations due to specific health conditions. Recipients’ symptoms should be addressed and managed as recipients with higher symptom distress and fatigue have lower scores on physical aspects of quality of life measures.8 Mobility limitations should be assessed and proper mobility aids and instruction provided as applicable. Additionally, assessment of social support and local resources for group activities or public access to exercise equipment can be explored with patients. Finally, recommendations for remaining physically active during inclement weather such as an indoor walking plan should be discussed. This study by Klompstra et al.7 adds significant findings to the literature on post-heart transplant recipients’ physical activity. Significant opportunities exist for further investigation into this topic. As heart transplant recipient longevity increases, more studies related to the impact of physical activity on long-term outcomes are needed. These include evaluation of mortality, cardiac allograft vasculopathy, and cardiovascular risk factors such as diabetes, hypertension, and obesity. A randomized clinical trial is currently evaluating the safety and efficacy of cardiac rehabilitation programmes and will add significant findings to this literature.9 Prior studies in heart transplant candidates have shown an association between physical activity and event-free survival to transplant, with more physical activity related to a decreased risk for adverse events.10 It is important to identify whether this trend is similar for patients post-transplant. Finally, although not identified in this paper, consideration related to the impact of mental health conditions such as depression on the recipients’ ability to perform physical activity should be given. Studies have shown that physical activity has protective effects and can reduce the depressive symptoms in adults; however, it is also possible that mental health concerns can reduce physical activity levels, as previously identified in heart transplant candidates.11,12 Melissa Owen (Conceptualization [lead]; Writing—original draft [lead]; Writing—review & editing [lead])
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Melissa I. Owen (2024) conducted an editorial in Heart transplantation (n=24). Physical activity was evaluated. Among 24 interviewed heart transplant recipients, slightly more than half were satisfied with their physical activity, which was facilitated by intrinsic motivation and hindered by physical symptoms.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: