Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In MOVE: An American Religion, Richard Kent Evans emphatically argues that MOVE-a mostly African American group, founded in Philadelphia in 1972 by John Africa (originally Vincent Leaphart), who were devoted to a natural lifestyle and a critique of Western values and systems-is a religion.However, Evans quickly dispatches with the debate over the religious qualities of MOVE.He simply states, "I have yet to come across a definition of religionsophisticated or simplistic, old or new-that MOVE does not positively match" (7).Rather, Evans wants to address how MOVE functions as a critical example of American religion and America religious history's negation or erasure of Black religion.MOVE, therefore, is not just a religion, but a uniquely American religion that is more often defined by the state than its adherents.Moreover, it is Evans's attention to space, racial geographies, and vocabularies of belonging that situates this text as an important contribution to the field of American religious studies, alternative religions, and the critical role of religion in theories of space and place.While Evans does not want to provide a new universal definition of religion, he persuasively argues that MOVE's relationship to that concept is central to understanding American religious identity.By exploring the multiple ways in which MOVE interacted with various systems, institutions, and the larger context of the United States, Evans persuasively argues that MOVE is a quintessential part of the twentieth-century encounter and relationship between religion, race, and the state.He examines MOVE's history with the courts, the everyday practices of MOVE people, and the sustained impact of MOVE on Philadelphia and Black religion.With specific and well-documented detail, Evans explores how MOVE was surveilled and controlled by the courts, the state, and the Black public.However, he frames MOVE's interactions with these larger systems by focusing on the stories of the participants, specifically Laverne Sims, an adherent and sister of the founder.The details of the lives of those involved with the ground-breaking court cases and the attention to the children and families impacted by the state-sponsored violence make this an important contribution to the histography of MOVE.In Evans's engagement with the everyday experiences of MOVE adherents, he highlights, through interviews, archives, and court documents, their practices, their encounters with the state, and the important role this religious community played in their lives.Evans pays specific attention to the ways in which MOVE had a unique impact on the lives of women in the movement and how their racialized and gendered bodies were treated by functionaries of the state.In so doing, Evans corrects for the ways that historiographies of religion and particularly Black religion have elided the critical relationship between women's bodies and voices and encounters with cultural and political institutions.Evans's attention to the courts, specifically MOVE women and the court, is not simply a rehashing of MOVE's encounter with the justice system; rather, he explores how these well-documented and recorded encounters with the legal system impacted the lives of the adherents.Rather than focusing on the debates around religious accommodations, Evans uses these multiple encounters to introduce how negotiations of legality, criminality, and belonging have long animated American religious histories.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Joseph L. Tucker Edmonds (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: