Key result
A critical appraisal of heart failure definitions highlights ambiguities in current criteria and proposes a more universal definition based on Newtonian physics and the Law of Conservation of Energy.
This critical appraisal highlights deficiencies in current heart failure definitions and proposes a new, universally applicable definition based on physical principles.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ambiguities in current HF definitions warrant scrutiny; physics-based proposal requires prospective validation before clinical adoption.
Defining heart failure (HF) is a matter of finding the most appropriate words to formulate the definiens for HF that will be universally applicable in all specific circumstances pertaining to the nature of HF. Currently available definitions of HF contain ambiguities and notable deficiencies such that non-heart failure medical conditions can become mislabelled as heart failure. Principles of how best to formulate definitions have been employed to provide a guide on how to appraise published definitions of HF. A fundamental requirement of a good definition is that it should be universal, and by this criterion, we need to question the validity of a conventional dogma that a collection of clinical diagnostic features are equivalent to HF definitions. A long-standing deficiency in HF definitions is the inability to take into account the quantifiable extent of functional impairment of the heart. Other traditional misconceptions surrounding HF definitions have also been addressed. In line with Derek Gibson's proposal, we have rephrased William Harvey's description of the cardiac role in maintaining the circulation in terms of Newtonian physics and of the Law of Conservation of Energy to reach a more universal and less ambiguous definition of HF, with the objective of advancing the science of HF and the treatment of this distressing condition.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tan et al. (2010) conducted a review in Heart failure. A critical appraisal of heart failure definitions highlights ambiguities in current criteria and proposes a more universal definition based on Newtonian physics and the Law of Conservation of Energy.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: