Key result
A streamlined method of scoring the ensemble-averaged impedance cardiogram showed excellent interrater reliability (ICC >.92) and concurrent validity (ICC >.97) compared to the conventional method.
Why the study?
Does a streamlined scoring method for ensemble-averaged impedance cardiograms provide comparable reliability and validity to a conventional method in undergraduate students?
Observational (n=40)
Does a streamlined scoring method for ensemble-averaged impedance cardiograms provide comparable reliability and validity to a conventional method in undergraduate students?
A streamlined method for scoring ensemble-averaged impedance cardiograms without beat-to-beat editing is faster and highly reliable compared to conventional methods.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Streamlined scoring may enhance feasibility of impedance cardiography; leaves open validation in clinical cardiovascular populations.
The interrater reliability and concurrent validity of two methods of scoring the ensemble-averaged impedance cardiogram were evaluated. Impedance cardiographic and electrocardiographic signals were recorded from 40 undergraduate men and women during a baseline rest period and a vocal mental arithmetic task period. Recordings were scored by four rates using a conventional method, involving ensemble averaging after careful editing of beat-to-beat waveforms, and a streamlined method, involving ensemble averaging without beat-to-beat editing. Intraclass correlations for interrater reliability exceeded .92, whereas intraclass correlations for concurrent validity exceeded .97, indicating excellent agreement between rates and scoring methods for all cardiac measures. The streamlined method was significantly faster than the conventional method. The results indicate that variations in beat-to-beat editing do not constitute a serious source of error in the ensemble-averaged impedance cardiogram and support the interrater reliability and concurrent validity of the two scoring methods.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kelsey et al. (1998) reported an observational. Streamlined scoring method (without beat-to-beat editing) vs. Conventional scoring method (with beat-to-beat editing) was evaluated on Interrater reliability and concurrent validity (ICC >.92 for interrater reliability, ICC >.97 for concurrent validity). A streamlined method of scoring the ensemble-averaged impedance cardiogram showed excellent interrater reliability (ICC >.92) and concurrent validity (ICC >.97) compared to the conventional method.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: