Key result
Right ventricular apical pacing resulted in a greater walking distance test distance compared to left ventricular pacing at six months, demonstrating less detrimental effects on LV synchrony.
Why the study?
Because pacing from the RV apex is not considered optimal, this study aimed to compare RV and LV pacing regarding LV function and dyssynchrony.
Does left ventricular pacing improve LV function and dyssynchrony compared to right ventricular pacing in patients with indications for pacemakers?
Observational (n=48)
No
Does left ventricular pacing improve LV function and dyssynchrony compared to right ventricular pacing in patients with indications for pacemakers?
Right ventricular apical pacing remains an appropriate standard for patients with normal or mildly impaired LV function (EF > 35%) requiring pacing.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
LV pacing may limit dyssynchrony versus RV apical pacing; leaves open need for outcome trials before practice change.
Background : Pacing from the apex of the RV is not considered optimal. This work aimed to assess and compare RV and LV pacing concerning LV function and dyssynchrony. Thirty-six patients who presented with indications for pacemakers were divided into three groups: 12 had LV pacing (lead was inserted from coronary sinus to lateral vein, the same procedure used in resynchronization pacing); 12 had RV pacing group (apical pacing only, not septal or outflow). 12 had Dual-chamber pacing. Control group: Twelve healthy subjects were included in this study. Results : RV pacing group: During the post-implantation period, the distance of the 6-MWT improved significantly, P= 0.006. The cardiac output (COP) during the preimplantation period and at the six-month follow-up (P= 0.003). The t-IVT (Total isovolumic time) variables at the pre-and post-implantation periods at six months (P= 0.005). LV pacing group: The comparison of the 6-MWT distance and the quality of life (QOL) score in the post-implantation period and at six months revealed a highly significant difference (improvement) Also in the median values of the PAP (RAP = Right atrial pressure), COP, MPI (MPI = Myocardial performance index), t-IVT, and Z (Z ratio = sum of the left ventricular ejection and filling times divided by RR interval) (P= 0.000). Conclusions : RVP seems to have less detrimental effects on LV synchrony and LV function. For those patients indicated for conventional pacemaker indications with normal or mildly impaired LV function with EF > 35%, RVA (right ventricular apical) pacing is still the gold standard pacing site.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elkholy et al. (2022) conducted an observational in Indications for permanent pacemaker implantation (e.g., sick sinus syndrome, complete heart block) (n=48). Left ventricular pacing vs. Right ventricular pacing was evaluated on 6-minute walk test distance at 6 months (p=0.015). Right ventricular apical pacing resulted in a greater walking distance test distance compared to left ventricular pacing at six months, demonstrating less detrimental effects on LV synchrony.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: