Key result
A single dye-dilution curve method showed good agreement with the oxygen method for calculating left-to-right shunt ratio (r=0.848, p<0.001), but yielded lower right-to-left shunt values.
Why the study?
Does a single dye-dilution curve method accurately quantitate bidirectional shunt compared to the oxygen method?
Does a single dye-dilution curve method accurately quantitate bidirectional shunt compared to the oxygen method?
Effect estimate: r = 0.848
p-value: p=<0.001
A single dye-dilution curve can accurately estimate left-to-right shunt ratios compared to the oxygen method, though it may underestimate right-to-left shunts.
May support dye-dilution for left-to-right shunt estimation; leaves open right-to-left accuracy pending prospective validation.
A method for quantitating intracardiac bidirectional shunt and estimating its blood flow is presented. Three curves, defined as "right-to-left shunt curve", "normal pathway curve", and "left-to-right shunt curve" were separately drawn from the original downstream dye-dilution curve, and their areas ?A'', A, A', respectively, were calculated in the conventional manner. A'/A showed left-to-right shunt ratio (QL-R%) even in the presence of right-to-left shunt. However, right-to-left shunt ratio (QR-L%) was given by (1-A'/A)/(A/A'' + 1--A'/A), and equalled A''/(A + A'') only when left-to-right shunt was absent (A' equals O). A''/(A + A) should become increasingly higher than QR-L% with rise in QL-R% (equals A'/A). The relationship between A''/(A + A'') and QR-L% for various A/A isopleths is shown by figure. A good agreement (r equals 0.848, p less than 0.001) was found between QL-R% values by the present method and those calculated by the oxygen method. In contrast, QR-L% values by the present method were consistently lower than those by the oxygen method; the difference was exaggerated especially in cases with history of cardiac failure, and these cases tended to show lower systemic flow. The average difference in QR-L% between the two methods, found in cases free from failure, was 7 per cent. This was thought to be ascribed to intrapulmonary physiological shunt.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Watanabe et al. (1975) studied Intracardiac bidirectional shunt. Single dye-dilution curve method vs. Oxygen method was evaluated on Left-to-right shunt ratio (QL-R%) (r = 0.848, p=<0.001). A single dye-dilution curve method showed good agreement with the oxygen method for calculating left-to-right shunt ratio (r=0.848, p<0.001), but yielded lower right-to-left shunt values.
Synapse has enriched 4 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: