Key result
Starr-Edwards and St. Jude mechanical valves generate less turbulent stress than Bjork-Shiley valves in vitro.
Why the study?
Mechanical heart valves generate complex flow patterns with elevated turbulent stresses that may contribute to thromboembolism and hemolysis, but comparative flow analyses among common valve designs are limited.
How do flow characteristics and turbulent stresses compare among Starr-Edwards, Bjork-Shiley c-c, and St. Jude Medical mechanical heart valves in the mitral position?
How do flow characteristics and turbulent stresses compare among Starr-Edwards, Bjork-Shiley c-c, and St. Jude Medical mechanical heart valves in the mitral position?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In an in vitro cardiac simulator, Starr-Edwards and St. Jude Medical mechanical valves demonstrated lower turbulent stresses compared to the Bjork-Shiley c-c valve, which may have implications for thromboembolism and hemolysis risk.
Three typical mechanical heart valves (Starr-Edwards, Bjork-Shiley c-c and St. Jude Medical) have been tested in the mitral position under pulsatile flow conditions, The test program included measurements of velocity and turbulent stresses at six downstream locations. The study was carried out using a sophisticated cardiac simulator in conjunction with a highly sensitive two-component laser Doppler anemometer system. The continuous monitoring of parametric time histories revealed useful details about the complex flow and also helped established location and time of the peak parameter values. Based on the experimental data, the following general conclusions can be drawn: (i) all 3 valve designs generated elevated turbulent stresses during acceleration and peak flow phases, presenting a possibility of thromboembolism, and perhaps, hemolysis; (ii) valve configuration and valve orientation significantly affect the flow characteristics; (iii) the Starr-Edwards valve with relatively a small opening area shows lower turbulent stresses; and (iv) the bileaflet design of the St. Jude Medical valve is also associated with lower turbulent stresses, as compared to the Bjork-Shiley c-c valve.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
AKUTSU et al. (1996) studied this question. Starr-Edwards, Bjork-Shiley c-c, and St. Jude Medical mechanical heart valves was evaluated on Velocity and turbulent stresses. In an in vitro cardiac simulator, Starr-Edwards and St. Jude Medical mechanical heart valves demonstrated lower turbulent stresses compared to the Bjork-Shiley c-c valve.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: