Key result
Metoprolol blunts adrenaline-induced pressor effects and increases heart rate compared to propranolol.
Why the study?
The haemodynamic effects of adrenaline during selective versus non-selective beta-adrenoreceptor blockade combined with antihypertensive therapy were not well characterized.
Does selective beta-1 blockade (metoprolol) compared to non-selective blockade (propranolol) improve hemodynamic responses to adrenaline in hypertensive patients on combined therapy?
Does selective beta-1 blockade (metoprolol) compared to non-selective blockade (propranolol) improve hemodynamic responses to adrenaline in hypertensive patients on combined therapy?
Selective beta-1 blockade with metoprolol provides a more favorable hemodynamic response to acute stress (modeled by adrenaline) compared to non-selective blockade with propranolol in hypertensive patients.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May favor selective beta-1 blockade for hemodynamic stability with adrenaline; leaves open outcome impact in hypertension.
Haemodynamic effects of adrenaline were studied in 27 hypertensive patients, succesively during treatment with propranol and metoprolol. In 12 patients beta-adrenoreceptor blockade was combined with diuretics and in 15 patients the blockade was combined with vasodilators. 2. During propranolol adrenaline caused a marked pressor effect: there was a considerable rise in systolic as well as in diastolic blood pressure and a marked fall in heart rate. During metoprolol there was only a slight rise in blood pressure and an increase in heart rate. 3. Forearm blood flow was decreased by adrenaline during propranolol and was increased during metoprolol. Calculated vascular resistance showed opposite changes. 4. Results were essentially the same when beta-adrenoreceptor blockade was combined with diuretics or with vasodilators and did not differ from previous results obtained in patients treated by blockade alone. 5. If adrenaline infusion can be considered as a model for acute stress, our results seem to favour a selective beta 1-adrenoreceptor blocking agent over a non-selective one, even when the blocker is combined with a diuretic or a vasodilator.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Houben et al. (1979) studied Hypertension (n=27). Metoprolol vs. Propranolol was evaluated on Haemodynamic effects of adrenaline (blood pressure, heart rate, forearm blood flow, vascular resistance). During adrenaline infusion, metoprolol caused only a slight rise in blood pressure and increased heart rate, whereas propranolol caused a marked pressor effect and decreased heart rate.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: