Key result
Portable INR monitors outperform insensitive lab thromboplastin methods but trail sensitive lab assays.
Why the study?
The accuracy of portable INR monitors has never been determined by comparison with a criterion standard INR determination.
How accurate are portable INR monitors and various laboratory methods compared to a criterion standard INR determination?
Observational
How accurate are portable INR monitors and various laboratory methods compared to a criterion standard INR determination?
Portable INR monitors provide satisfactory accuracy for clinical use, performing better than laboratory methods that use insensitive thromboplastins but worse than those using highly sensitive reagents.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Monitor INR accuracy appears satisfactory versus criterion standard; leaves open whether routine use improves clinical outcomes versus lab testing.
BACKGROUND: Portable instruments that measure the prothrombin time and automatically calculate the international normalized ratio (INR) with the use of a drop of whole blood have simplified the treatment of patients who are receiving warfarin therapy. The accuracy of these portable monitors has never been determined by comparing INR results with a criterion (gold) standard INR determination. METHODS: Duplicate whole-blood INR determinations were made with two commercially available portable INR monitors. Duplicate frozen-plasma samples were measured with four different thromboplastin reagents, each with a different international sensitivity index. The criterion standard INR was determined by using an international reference thromboplastin and the manual tilt-tube technique. Agreement was evaluated by determining how accurately laboratory and monitor INR determinations matched criterion standard values in designating a sample to be within or outside of currently recommended INR target ranges. RESULTS: Two of the laboratory methods, which used relatively sensitive thromboplastins, showed close agreement with the criterion standard, whereas two laboratory methods that used less sensitive thromboplastin reagents showed poor agreement. Both of the portable monitors fell between these extremes. The two best laboratory methods ere significantly better (P < .003) than both monitors, which in turn were better (P < .003) than the remaining two laboratories. CONCLUSIONS: There is large interlaboratory variation in the accuracy of INR determinations. Laboratory methods that used insensitive (high international sensitivity index) thromboplastins performed poorly. Accuracy of monitor measurements appears satisfactory.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Scott S. Kaatz (1995) conducted an observational in Warfarin therapy. Portable INR monitors vs. Criterion standard INR was evaluated on Agreement with criterion standard values in designating a sample to be within or outside of currently recommended INR target ranges (p=<.003). Portable INR monitors demonstrated satisfactory accuracy, performing better than laboratory methods using insensitive thromboplastins but worse than sensitive laboratory methods.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: