Why the study?
Most speckle tracking echocardiographic studies have targeted left ventricular mechanics, with no data regarding left atrial phasic function in pregnancy and particularly in gestational hypertension.
Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Population
Women with gestational hypertension and age-matched normotensive pregnant women
Comparison
Gestational hypertension vs age-matched normotensive pregnancy
Design
Echocardiographic comparative study
Follow-up
1-year follow-up
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Pregnancy may be regarded as a cardiovascular ‘stress test’ and hypertension during pregnancy has been consistently shown to be associated with an increased risk of both maternal and fetal adverse outcomes [1]. Thus a comprehensive evaluation of blood pressure (BP) status during pregnancy has relevant implications for public health as hypertension occurs as a complication in 5–7% of all pregnancies [2]. Preeclampsia, characterized by new-onset hypertension, proteinuria, and multisystem involvement, remains the most important cause of maternal mortality. In addition, pregnancy-induced hypertension is now considered a marker for future cardiac and metabolic disease [3]. Finally, the increasing burden of chronic hypertension among pregnant women because of the growing incidence of pregnancies in women older than 35 years, poses new important challenges in the management of hypertensive disorders in this setting. Although a growing body of evidence support the relevance of out-of-office BP (i.e. home and ambulatory BP monitoring) in risk assessment of adverse pregnancy outcomes, the definition of hypertension in pregnancy is so far based only on office (or in-hospital) BP values (SBP ≥140 mmHg and/or DBP ≥90 mmHg) and classified in two stages: mild (140–159/90–109 mmHg) and severe (≥160/110 mmHg) hypertension [2]. Moreover, several different entities of hypertension during pregnancy should be differentiated: preexisting hypertension (i.e. diagnosed before 20 weeks of gestation); gestational hypertension (i.e. occurring after 20 weeks of gestation); preeclampsia–eclampsia; preeclampsia in women with already known chronic hypertension; antenatally unclassifiable hypertension when increased BP was measured after 20 weeks of gestation [2]. Hypertensive disorders during pregnancy are associated with high maternal risks including placental abruption, stroke, multiple organ failure, and disseminated intravascular coagulation. The fetus is at high-risk of intrauterine growth retardation (25% of cases of preeclampsia), prematurity (27% of cases of preeclampsia), and intrauterine death (4% of cases of preeclampsia) [2]. The volume load in the pregnancy is significantly increased whereas the peripheral vascular resistance is decreased. Numerous echocardiographic studies reported that even healthy pregnant women before delivery could have cardiac maladaptation to volume overload characterized by left ventricular (LV) dilatation, which completely resolves within the first year postpartum [4]. Moreover, cardiovascular maladaptation is more pronounced in preeclampsia with manifest diastolic dysfunction that has been shown to occur in up to 40–45% of the cases [5]. In contrast to what happens in healthy pregnant women, echocardiographic alterations in women with preeclampsia do not resolve entirely after delivery. Recent investigations have shown that advanced echocardiographic techniques, such as two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D) speckle tracking are able to detect subtle cardiac changes (not easily identifiable with standard echocardiography) in women with healthy pregnancy [6], preeclampsia [7], or other types of pregnancy-related hypertensive disorders [8–11]. A recent 2D speckle tracking echocardiographic study by Clemmensen et al.[12]. documented that women with a history of early preeclampsia were more likely to have subclinical impairment of LV function 12 years after preeclampsia than their counterparts with a history of late preeclampsia and the control group. This finding highlights the clinical significance of evaluation of LV mechanics in women with hypertensive disorders during pregnancy. It is worth noting that most of 2D or 3D speckle tracking echocardiographic studies have targeted LV mechanics, whereas there are no data regarding left atrial phasic function in the pregnancy and particularly in women with gestational hypertension. Sonaglioni et al.[13] in the current issue of the Journal for the first time showed that left atrial phasic function was significantly impaired in women with gestational hypertension in comparison with age-matched normotensive pregnant women. The authors reported that left atrial reservoir, conduit, and pump functions, assessed by left atrial strain and strain rate analyses, were significantly lower in women with gestational hypertension than in normotensive pregnant women. Moreover, they showed that LV diastolic function parameters were significantly impaired and LV filling pressure significantly elevated in women with gestational hypertension in comparison with normotensive pregnant females. Parameters of LV structural remodeling (LV mass index and relative wall thickness) were significantly increased in women with gestational hypertension, whereas LV systolic function parameters and volumes did not substantially differ between the two groups. In addition, subclinical vascular remodeling, as assessed by ultrasonography (i.e. increased common carotid intima–media thickness) paralleling cardiac involvement was found in women with gestational hypertension. Other investigators reported similar findings regarding left atrial enlargement, impaired LV diastolic function, and LV hypertrophy among women with preeclampsia [8–10,14]. As for left atrial function, a recent study by Tasar et al.[15] showed that left atrial reservoir and pump function, assessed with left atrial strain and strain rates, gradually decreased from the first trimester to the third trimester during normal pregnancy, whereas the measurements in the postpartum period gradually increased and returned to the initial levels 6 months after delivery. This was not the case for left atrial conduit function during or after pregnancy. The authors claimed that probable reason for decrement in left atrial strain was progressive subtle LV diastolic impairment that may occur during physiological pregnancy. This is in agreement with the results of Sonaglioni et al.[13] even though they did not measure left atrial strain values during pregnancy. Neither of these two studies provided left atrial strain values in unpregnant women in order to compare with pregnant women with gestational hypertension. The reduction of left atrial reservoir and pump function strain in normal pregnancy indicated that left atrial remodeling and progressive LV diastolic dysfunction might be normal cardiac adaptation to the increased preload. However, comparing values obtained in normal pregnancy [15] and in gestational hypertension [13], one could detect significantly lower left atrial strain among women with gestational hypertension. This indicates additive or even cumulative negative effect of gestational hypertension and increased afterload on left atrial phasic function. However, the authors of these studies [13,15], used different echocardiographic vendors and it is well known that assessment of strain is highly vendor-dependent analysis. An important finding of the current study is that left atrial global strain 23.5% or less predicted persistence of hypertension at 1-year follow-up with very high sensitivity and specificity (100 and 91%, respectively) [13]. Left atrial longitudinal strain and office BP were predictors of persistent hypertension in women with gestational hypertension, whereas other important clinical and echocardiographic parameters, such as age, glomerular filtration rate, left atrial volume index, LV ejection fraction and parameters of LV diastolic function did not exhibit an independent value in predicting persistent hypertension. It should be noted that the cut-off value for left atrial global longitudinal strain provided by Sonaglioni et al.[13] was significantly lower than those reported in previous studies and their meta-analysis. Therefore, the extrapolation to population with different demographic and clinical characteristics should be done with caution. Indeed, a large meta-analysis of 40 studies including a total of 2.542 healthy subjects reported that normal left atrial reservoir strain ranged from 27.6 to 59.8%, with the average value 39.4% (95% CI 38–40.8%) [16]. Nevertheless, the prediction of left atrial global longitudinal strain on persistent hypertension 1 year after pregnancy in women with gestational hypertension is very important because it provides an additional echocardiographic index, which could help to identify women at higher risk for persistent arterial hypertension. In clinical circumstances, the evaluation of left atrial global longitudinal strain provides easy and rapid assessment of LV filling pressure [17] as well as accurate identification of subclinical cardiac damage, independently of LV strain [18] (Table 1).TABLE 1: Left ventricular and left atrial mechanics in normotensive and hypertensive women during pregnancyConsidering the fact that Sonaglioni et al.[13] showed that left atrial global longitudinal strain, unlike conventional parameters of LV diastolic dysfunction, was an independent predictor of persistent hypertension one should consider including the left atrial longitudinal strain evaluation in the echocardiographic exam during pregnancy. The authors of the current study used P-P gating for the left atrial strain evaluation [13], which means that onset of P-wave in electrocardiogram was used as the zero-reference point for the generation of the strain curves instead of R wave that is commonly used for evaluation of LV strain. There is lack of agreement where the zero-reference point should be in evaluation of left atrial strain. In the literature, most researches still used R-R gating for both, left atrial and LV strain. The P wave of the electrocardiogram represents atrial depolarization, which is followed by atrial contraction (at the peak of P wave). Therefore, P-P gating seems to be the more physiological method for left atrial strain assessment. The recently published consensus paper of the EACVI/ASE/Industry Task Force to standardize deformation imaging suggested that there are two possible zero points for determination of left atrial strain: zero reference set at LV end-diastole and zero reference set at the onset of left atrial contraction [19]. Furthermore, this document provided formula for conversion of left atrial strain values from one to another approach [19]. Left atrial longitudinal strain values, which refer to the LV end-diastole as baseline (R-R gating) are larger because the left atrial wall is shortest at this point, whereas left atrial strain values, which refer to the onset of atrial contraction (P-P gating) as baseline are smaller because the left atrial wall is somewhat longer at this time point. Therefore, normal values for left atrial strain are dependent on zero reference point. The difference in absolute values is not large, but should be taken into account when different studies are compared. A further interesting finding of the study by Sonaglioni et al.[13] is that women with gestational hypertension showed a greater carotid intima–media thickness than their normotensive counterparts. This might suggest that the exposure to high BP in women with gestational hypertension may induce early atherosclerotic changes in vascular wall and consequently increase intima–media thickness. However, an alternative explanation to the more pronounced subclinical carotid damage may be that women with gestational hypertension had a more marked atherogenic profile compared with normotensive pregnant women (i.e. higher prevalence of dyslipidemia: 59% vs. 4%, P < 0.0001). Finally, the main limitations of this study are limited number of subjects and lack of echocardiographic follow-up during pregnancy and afterwards. At the same time, these limitations are providing future directions in this field of research. Further longitudinal studies with a larger number of participants and several follow-up echocardiographic examinations during and after pregnancy are necessary to evaluate the influence of gestational hypertension and other hypertensive disorders on cardiovascular remodeling and outcome. The available evidence suggests the usefulness of including left atrial phasic function assessment as the part of conventional echocardiographic examination in pregnancy, even though we still need more data in this research area. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cuspidi et al. (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: