Key result
Polyurethane pacing leads linked to ~20% insulation failure at 5 years versus silicone.
Why the study?
Long-term insulation failure rates of different types of pervenous pacing leads implanted from 1979 to 1992 were not well characterized.
Do urethane pacing leads have a higher rate of insulation failure compared to silicone pacing leads?
Cohort (n=117)
No
Do urethane pacing leads have a higher rate of insulation failure compared to silicone pacing leads?
Urethane pacing leads, particularly types 6972 and 4002, exhibit significantly higher long-term insulation failure rates compared to silicone leads, necessitating strict patient follow-up.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Urethane leads associated with higher insulation failure than silicone; leaves open material preference for new implants pending prospective data.
Long-term study of insulation failure of pervenous pacing leads implanted at the hospital from May 1979 to December 1992 was conducted. Subjected pacing leads were 107 ventricular leads (10 leads of 6972 type, 10 of 4002 type, 26 of 4012 type, 45 of 5062 type, and 8 of other types) and 42 atrial leads (16 leads of 4512 type, 3 of 4058 type, 15 of 4504 type, 4 of 4524 type, and 4 of others), totally 149 leads. No insulation failure was detected among 42 atrial leads, howevr, the failure was frequently found among ventricular leads, especially urethan ones. Insulation failure free rates 5 and 7 years after implantation were 80% and 40% in 6972 type, 70% and 70% in 4002 type, and 96.2% and 92% in 4012 type, respectively. When compared with the rates of 100% and 100% for silicone 5062 leads, 6972 and 4002 types showed a significantly lower insulation failure free rates. It is concluded that the patients implanted these urethan leads should be strictly followed up.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Onoe et al. (1994) conducted a cohort in Patients with implanted endocardial pacing leads (n=117). Polyurethane ventricular pacing leads (types 6972 and 4002) vs. Silicone ventricular pacing leads (type 5062) was evaluated on Insulation failure free rate at 5 years (p=<0.01). Polyurethane ventricular pacing leads (types 6972 and 4002) demonstrated lower insulation failure free rates at 5 and 7 years compared to silicone leads.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: