Key result
Porcine pulmonary mechanical valve replacement causes rapid terminal thrombosis, sharply cutting survival compared to ovine models.
Why the study?
Recent developments questioned the validity of sheep for evaluating mechanical heart valves, and pigs were proposed as a better alternative due to a more comparable coagulation system. This study compared the thrombogenicity of sheep and pigs in an orthotopic pulmonary valve replacement model.
Does an orthotopic pulmonary valve replacement porcine model elicit greater mechanical heart valve thrombosis compared to an ovine model in the absence of long-term antithrombotic therapy?
Does an orthotopic pulmonary valve replacement porcine model elicit greater mechanical heart valve thrombosis compared to an ovine model in the absence of long-term antithrombotic therapy?
Unlike sheep, which failed to develop significant thrombosis, the porcine orthotopic pulmonary valve replacement model rapidly and reliably induces mechanical valve thrombosis, supporting a shift to pigs as the standard preclinical model for mechanical valve thrombogenicity research.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Porcine models rapidly induce mechanical valve thrombosis unlike sheep; supports shift to pigs for preclinical thrombogenicity research but leaves clinical translation open.
Objective Animal models are indispensable for the development of valve prostheses like we currently know them. Recent developments have questioned the validity of sheep as the model of choice for the evaluation of mechanical heart valves. The pig has been raised as a better alternative due to a more comparable coagulation system. We therefore compared the thrombogenicity of the sheep compared to the pig in a model of pulmonary valve replacement. Methods Pigs (n = 12) and sheep (n = 5) underwent pulmonary valve replacement with a mechanical valve in orthotopic position. No antithrombotic medication of any kind was given. Follow-up period was 5 months or until established valve thrombosis. Valve performance was assessed by monthly cardiac ultrasounds combined with post-mortem macro- and microscopical analysis of the valve and downstream organs. Results In the pig cohort, valve thrombosis was established after less than a month in all but one animal. Post-mortem valve examination showed terminal valve thrombosis with immobilized hinges. In the sheep cohort, all animals completed the follow-up period of 5 months. At post-mortem examination, all valves were free from any thrombi or deposits with both leaflets mobile. Conclusion The sheep model appears not thrombogenic enough to elicit mechanical valve thrombosis in the highly thrombogenic pulmonary position. Contrarily, the porcine model elicits massive thrombosis at a fast rate in an identical position. These findings confirm that we should shift to the pig as a standard for (mechanical valve) thrombosis research.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Langenaeken et al. (2024) studied Mechanical heart valve thrombosis (preclinical orthotopic pulmonary valve replacement model) (n=17). Porcine model of orthotopic pulmonary valve replacement with a 21mm bileaflet mechanical valve vs. Ovine (sheep) model of orthotopic pulmonary valve replacement with a 21mm bileaflet mechanical valve (2 St. Jude Medical, 3 On-X) with identical postoperative protocol was evaluated on Established terminal mechanical valve thrombosis and survival (days) (p=<0.001). Porcine orthotopic pulmonary valve replacement elicited terminal mechanical valve thrombosis within 1 month in 11 of 12 pigs versus 0 of 5 sheep, reducing mean survival to.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: